Vogue Covers - Who Should and Shouldn't?

[sunflower123]

Should:
Nicole Kidman
Kate Moss
Vanessa Paradis
Models
David Bowie-- hey! It could happin ^.^

Shouldn't:
Nicole Richie, Paris Hilton, Emmy Rossum, Mischa Barton, Sienna Miller (although she already has been) any Desperate Housewife, SJP (she has been too...), Cameron Diaz, Lucy Liu, Drew Barrymore, Hilary Duff, Lindsay Lohan, Ashlee Simpson, Jessica Simpson, Kate Bosworth, the OlsenTwins, pop stars,

 

[Bella_Lass334]

Should:

Nicole Kidman
Keira Knightley
Natalie Portman
Rachel McAdams
Gemma Ward
Kate Moss
Natalie Vodianova
Salma Hayek
Other classy, respectable women

Shouldn't:

Paris
Nicole
Britney
Christina
Mischa Barton
Jessica Alba
Lindsay Lohan
Hilary Duff

 

[funkalicious]

Should

Cate Blanchett
Catherine Zeta Jones
Keira Knightley
Natalie Portman
Nicole Kidman
Scarlett Johansson
Uma Thurman
Zhang Ziyi

Shouldn't
Every other celeb?

 

[taismith82]

SHOULD:
Tilda Swinton
Stella Tennant
Vanessa Paradis(not just in France either)
Irina Lazreanu
Isabeli Fontana
Liv Tyler
Isabella Rossellini
Drew Barrymore
Jacquetta Wheeler
Sienna Miller
Penelope Cruz
Amanda Peet
Ivana Milecevic
Linda Vojtova
Karolina Kurkova
Lisa Cant
Hana Soukupova
Daria Werbowy
Camilla Belle
Winona Ryder

 

[Royal-Galliano]

I can't believe i'm saying this but Sienna looks good in that Vogue UK cover B)

I'd say everybody else would look good in that... it's just a great photo

 

[LAlights]

the day paris hilton graces the cover of vogue...oy! i dont even want to think about it.

what do you guys think of fashion designers being featured on the cover? or stylists (rachel zoe. etc.) ?

 

[Miss Dalloway]

I think that is a great idea i alredy thought about that and it would be great who of the many fashionable man would deserve to be on cover!

 

[aquamis]

To Aquamis, from your post I can see, that you like rumours, especially this, which are untrue (this thing about Nicole Kidman) Maybe you should go back and read some new InTouch or National Esquair and do not post your opinions here...

Sorry, but i've never read InTouch and i've never heard of National Esquair.
What i was referring to was published in the March 2005 edition of Harper's Bazaar. And correct me if i'm wrong but isn't this forum asking for our opinion on something, or do they need proven scientific research on who shouldn't be on Vogue.

 

[litchickuk]

NO CELEBRITIES SHOULD HAVE A VOGUE COVER. they can have interviews etc inside but the cover is for models

 

[bluedolphin]

1

SHOULD
me!!!!!!
Nicole Kidman
MAGGIE chueng
DUJUAN
ziyi zhang

NOT
Paris Hilton
Lindsay Lohan
Jessica Simpson
Britney
Christina Aguilera

 

[bluedolphin]

other should
Natalie Portman
Rachel McAdams
Gemma Ward
Kate Moss
Natalie Vodianova

 

[peppi]

milla jovovitch
sofia coppola
julianne moore
edie falco
maggie gyllenhaal
erukah badu
kirsten dunst
alicia keyes
models!

 

[Miss Dalloway]

SHOULD&SHOULDN"T:
Nicole Kidman(always)
Kate Moss(almost always)
Sienna Miller(sometimes)
Victoria Beckham(at least once)
Sarah Jessica Parker(never again)
Drew Barrymore(enough)
Britney Spears(never ever again)
Keira Knghitley(just stope)
Melania Trump(again-because she is so vogue)
No celebritiy that never heard of a lanvin or dont know nothing about fashion!MODELS,MODELS,MODELS(ALWAYS)

 

[chanelnumber5]

Should:
Nicole Kidman
Liv Tyler
Keria Knightly
Maggie Gyllenhaal
Kirsten Dunst
Cate Blanchett
Natalie Portman
Any model
I also think it would be nice if about once a year they went out talent spotting and put a range of women and men on the cover, as there is so many beautiful people out there yet to be discovered
Shouldnt:
SJP
Paris Hilton
Lindasy Lohan
Brittany Spears
Sienna Miller
Kate Bosworth
Katie Holmes
Olsen twins
Victoria Beckham
Mischa Barton

 

[BooBah]

i have to say, as much as i know this will be taken badly, id have no problem putting the olsen twins on the cover of vogue. they're both incredibly beautiful girls and theyve definitely started more fashion trends than anyone else in the past few years. Most of the celebrities out there that are considered for the cover dont have half the style or love for fashion that these girls do, and have probably adopted some aspect of their style.

i mean, come one, sienna miller???

 

[Zoolander]

I wonder if this October when Marie Antoinette comes out Kirsten will get the cover. Or maybe her AND sofia? that would be too cool.

But Sofia's home seems to be Paris Vogue, which is fine

 

[lola belle]

Should: Gwyneth and Chris Martin. The Fug Girls. Scarlett Johansson. Phoebe Philo. Sasha Pivovarova. And maybe Jared Leto, but that's mostly just because I want to look at Jared Leto and has nothing to do with fashion. Sue me!

Shouldn't: Kevin Federline. Although I admit, if he made the cover I would totally buy it, he's my guilty pleasure! And pleeeeaaasseee no more Gemma Ward. I'm getting tired of her very fast.

 

[mme]

More Kate

 

[simple_elegance]

has Liv Tyler ever been on Vogue? she should if she hasn't.

 

[Rach884]

Should:

** Mandy Moore (she has quite a few movies coming out)
** Sarah Michelle Gellar (almost 5-6 projects hitting theaters this year)
** Evangeline Lilly (Lost)
** Rachel McAdams

Shouldn't

**Paris Hilton
**Lindsay Lohan
**Nicole Richie
**Jessica Simpson

I swear if I was to ever see them on the cover, I would run away in horror