Vogue Germany May 2017 : Kate Moss, Lara Stone & Irina Shayk by Peter Lindbergh

[MDNA]

 

[Vitamine W]

Hmm, they all seem a bit off. Especially Irina looks like she is popping a doodle bubble.

 

[Lola701]

The Kate cover is glamour and beautiful, the Lara one is more cinematic and the Irina one is a little bit more classic but the overall thing is kinda boring.
I don't find anything really exciting about that.
Maybe i'm just bored by Lindbergh...

 

[Valentine27]

Kate's looks déjà vu, Lara looks dead, and I couldn't care less about Irina.
Not very exciting!

 

[Nymphaea]

All three aren't very good, too much reality for me. Kate is lucky because she got black and white, it's more flattering.

 

[tigerrouge]

I like the idea of this, but aside from Kate's, I'm not so keen on the execution of the other two images.


Lara's gloomy portrait might have its merits, but its unconventional nature means I can't see it acting as catnip on the newsstand, not in the same way as a more glamorous shot might perform.

 

[mariemaud]

I can't even tell how much I dislike Kate Moss, once I liked her but know I'm bored to the bones...I can even say I hate her look
but I was excited to open the thread for Lara and Irina by Lindbergh...it didn'et reach my expectations sadly !
REALLY not as exciting as it sounds

 

[Creative]

OMG, those are terrible images!

 

[Miss Dalloway]

Really over these "natural" covers, but out of all the only one that works, is Kate's!

Oh and wow Irina is getting quite a few of Vogue covers this year.

 

[Benn98]

I hate myself for this, but Irina's got the best cover!! It's not a conventional beauty shot, and her beauty here looks like a myriad of ethnic makeups, simply love it. I like the diversity of these beauties, but would really prefer each girl to get her own month.

How did they get Kate to share anyway?? She's like Gisele, they hate sharing covers.

 

[hfgl]

I'm so bored of the Peter Lindbergh/ famous models/ black and white shtick.

 

[magsaddict]

at least Kate actually looks like Kate here, and although i like Lara, her cover turned out the worst by far, through no fault of her own. Irina's is fresh, but none of the covers are very fashion. Why do Vogue Germany do multi covers? They aren't Vogue Italia by a long shot.

 

[kokobombon]

I only like Kate´s, the only one with some glamour imo. Hate the layout though, what is that chalk font?

 

[TREVOFASHIONISTO]

they all look like escaped mental patients

 

[Benn98]

at least Kate actually looks like Kate here, and although i like Lara, her cover turned out the worst by far, through no fault of her own. Irina's is fresh, but none of the covers are very fashion. Why do Vogue Germany do multi covers? They aren't Vogue Italia by a long shot.

Now that you mention VI, they also had the chalk font (I've been told it's Lindbergh's signature). At least these covers are better than the VI ones last year.

Also agree about Lara's shot being the worst. I'm quite over the idea of multi-covers, but Kate's shot makes me yearn those Linbergh/Yurman days when she made ugly jewels look chic.

 

[narcyza]

Kate's cover is amazing! Much better than Vogue UK.

 

[Phuel]

Was hoping for a threesome cover… sigh...

As is, Kate’s is gorgeous. And the only cover that looks like any effort was made: Nice, classic layout and color-palette. Lara’s cover—my god, she always looks like a milkmaid now, and they shot her when she’s not looking in tone. And Irina’s hat makes it look like it’s a part of her hair; she would look tons tons tons better, and thus a stronger cover had they just taken the hat off and let her hair down.

And the chalk type— so literal with the “natural” concept it’s embarrassing LOL (Looks like Peter’s handwriting, so I wonder how much extra they were charged for that…???)

Thanks MDNA.

 

[jeffandtheworld]

In love with Lara's cover. Cinematic and sensual - Very Lindbergh.

 

[Sensation]

Kate's cover is the only one I like.

 

[happycanadian]

I'm baffled by the comments!

I think these are great. Kate's has that classic Lindbergh glamour. Lara's is cinematic and unique.

But - for me - Irina's is the standout. Not cause it's the best cover, per se, but because in the photo she's emoting a totally different energy than I've seen from her. It's soft and vulnerable and natural. Which I honestly didn't think she had in her. Obviously she's a stunning woman and certainly a very capable model (really, one of the best at what she does - which is alluring, strong, sensuality). But this is something new and for that I'm impressed!