Maybelline Shadow Effects Eye Pencils: They start coming off almost as soon as you put them on.
Maybelline Cool Effects Eye Pencils: Now while I do like these and was sad to give them up they were just not worth the price. At first they were great, but then about 1/2 way through the pencil they would dry up and thus pull on my eye too much and they would become detached from the wood making them impossible to sharpen w/o constantly breaking them and were also prone to falling out all together.
Rimmel 100% Waterproff Mascara: Okay the first time, but a big clumpy mess every time afterwards. I only bought it because I was poor and $5.00 was what I could afford and I like their eyeliner a lot so...but yeah it ended up costing me more in the long run because it's a worthless mascara. Have not used it since I bought L’Oréal Paris - Lash Architect Waterproof Mascara and I threw the Rimmel away a few days ago while organizing my make-up drawer.
Stila Lip Glaze: I am yet to find a lip gloss that comes with a brush attached that I actually like. I get them because I can put them on w/o touching my lips, good while at work, but I rarely end up using them in the end. That aside the gloss seems to take a lifetime to come out and either dispenses too little or too much, never know which it will do at any given time. I find it too shiny, I wanted something more subtle like tinted Prada lip balms and I don't like the way it feels on my lips. It might be okay for $5.00, but not for the $20.00 I paid. I don't consider it much better then the Rimmel Volume Boost Liquid Lipcolour I bought for I think $3.00-4.00.
Burt's Bees Lip Shimmer: So I use the regular clear BB lip balm all the time and love it, so I try the tinted stuff and loathe it. Dries out my lips making them flaky and the color slides around too much if that makes sense.
ULTA Cosmetics Brand Eyeshadow: I have two of these because it was buy 1 get 1 free. They were a pain in the *** from start to finish. I really loved one of the colors but I just got sick of working with it. They were hard to apply w/o causing a giant mess and though it would start coming off only a few hours after applied if it fell on my face while putting it on it was nearly impossible to get off. I won't buy their eyeshadows again.