Raf for Jil was perfect, no question about that. Sarah Mower was damn right in reviewing the first WW show under Raf's direction: it takes a northern soul to understand another one (then, maybe, we can leave to a different thread the discussion on what was Raf's and what was Patrick VO's merit in shaping the new identity for the house...).
One thing is for sure: The Meiers never really got the spirit of Jil, it's like they didn't even know where they were...their work was as bad as the brief, luckily forgotten tenure of Milan Vukmirovic during the Prada years...