Okay, I caved on this bag too. I saw it in person at the Choo store when I was in Vegas a few weeks ago and couldn't stop thinking about it so I ordered it. I got it last week and I'm in love. My thoughts...
I love that the navy is so dark that it works with black. The leather is FABULOUSLY soft.... very fondle-worthy. I've only carried it for a week now but I'm not finding that the leather scratches easily--so far, so good on that. I LOVE the gold hardware and to me it stands out more in person that in the pics. On the negative side, it doesn't have an exterior pocket (why???? This drives me nuts) and it's a wee bit hard to get into. It's not light either, but eh. Overall, I LOVE LOVE LOVE this bag. I can't believe what I spent on it (although I used the 10% off code from Saks) but I have no regrets so far.
Oh, and the inside is so pretty too... love the pretty lavender ribbon.
OH... yes, it's sold out on the Saks site, but if anyone wants it... call the Boston, Beverly Hills, or NY store. As of yesterday, those stores had it in stock but only in black and brown (no navy).