Seriously what do you have against this girl? Is it because she has had more campaign, runway, and overall success than your precious Natalia? And you really know it's the truth.
The only reason Natalia got that first Vanity Fair piece was because she picked herself up from poverty (mostly by marrying in to money
). They weren't interested in her "stellar career" (mostly because she has been EXCESSIVELY limited to Calvin), they cared more about her rich husband and her rags to riches story (Cinderalla, everyone loves it).
But the problem with your argument is that Natalia too is washed out. And personally I don't find her all that attractive. Sure, she gets editorials, but she hasn't had that many SOLO covers. She went commercial, but yet unlike Karolina, she has hardly any fame. She doesn't do the PRESTIGIOUS campaigns like YSL or Prada. Younger and more beautiful girls knocked her off her "number 1 girl" throne a while back. Look at Gemma, Daria, and Hana. They are all even more well known than Natalia. (And Hana is seriously moving through the ranks...)
And about Karolina's profile, well at least she is attractive from the front and I can't say that about Natalia (have you seen how creepy she looks on the run way?)