I love both but I'm very picky on how round or how pointy they are:
I see a lot of round shoes that to me look like flight waitresses shoes and that's a big NO for me! My mom owned black round shoes that she gave me, I was wearing them once at an airport and saw a group of flight waitresses walking past me and they were wearing almost the same shoes as I was! No I did not feel good

and my boyfriend thought it was funny
I like pointy shoes but they can get a fat feeling to them, like the pointy toe can come too quickly, I like the pointy toe to be "slim", don't want to look like I have six toes

And I don't want the toe to be too long. I also most often want the toe to be straight, not curled up, I though own pointy boots from Bianco who have a slighty curled up toe and I like these boots a lot, but they are in my opinion very special

... but all other shoes with a slightly curled up toe I've seen I haven't liked.
I'm really picky on my shoes! I want more round shoes in my closet but here in Iceland every damn shoe in the stores are pointed, that's Iceland today, follow the "fashion" (meaning Icelandic fashion only) or be a granny looking dork. Sure I've seen round shoes, from Irregular Choice, haven't seen many round shoes exept from the stores who cell that brand.