Lapin de Lune - Hi! this is so weird, but I literally--just minutes ago--right-click saved your before-and-after bangs pic from the bang thread! I absolutely loved your transition and decided I might go that way this weekend when I visit my stylist!
Anyway, I'm so sorry you've had so many nay-saying stylists. Frankly, it sounds to me they have absolutely no business being stylists in the first place giving such shoddy advice and all.
Can I tell you what I think?
Firstly, you'd be PERFECT for red!
You have the porcelain skin, blue-green colored eyes and light hair that all natural redheads have! So with that out of the way, all that's left is finding a stylist who
gets this! Try googling salons that cater to "extreme" color, those are the places that are going to be the most open minded, experienced and able to give you the
right shade of red. In the world of color, especially at salons, red is horribly under stocked. There are one zillions shades of blonde, brown and black (blue-black!) but maybe five for red--and they're usually brown-based, ruddy or auburn.
For your gorgeous coloring, the natural choice would be a carrot-orange red shade. Think baby blonde golden orange. That color will be absolutely ravishing on you and, really, is only a shade different from your natural blonde color. Blonde-based red (orange) will be so lovely on you, I wish I could reach through the computer screen and do it for you!
Be sure to take pictures of the exact color you want with you to the salon, and emphasize what you're looking for: natural looking, blonde-based,
not brown based. If they still say no, for whatever reason, keep looking for another salon. The trick is to find the right stylist-- someone who's truly experienced in the realm of color, especially red!
Now if you can't find a salon, I would happily PM you all the necessary ingredients you'd need to do it on your own (really easy, NOT harsh on the hair at all! it's not necessary, your hair is already so light so there's no need to lift with peroxide). If so, just let me know!
Good luck and please post pics if you do end up going red!