The premiere issue of Style.com/Print ranked the top ten collections of ss 2012 | the Fashion Spot
  • MODERATOR'S NOTE: Please can all of theFashionSpot's forum members remind themselves of the Forum Rules. Thank you.

The premiere issue of Style.com/Print ranked the top ten collections of ss 2012

chanelh

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2011
Messages
1,055
Reaction score
445
According to the premiere issue of Style.com/Print , the top ten rank of next year spring summer collection will be:
1.Balenciaga
2.Lanvin
3.Prada
4.Givenchy
5.Proenza
6.Chanel
7.Trussardi
8.Jil Sander
9.Valentino

and here is also a list ranked by readers' choice
Chanel,LV,Prada,Dolce,Balenciaga,McQueen,Givenchy,Burberry,Gucci,MJ





resource:the sina weibo of Vogue China Editor-In-Chief angelica cheung
 
did they really think that trussardi put out a stronger collection than alexander mcqueen?!
 
there should be a riot for having Chanel or either lists but whatever. Lists are lists for a reason: to start confusion and counter opinions.
 
Things I've noticed.
same old brands they rank every year
all of them are advertisers
users list is entirely conducted of status symbol brands (one might argue that McQueen doesn't belong to them. Think of skull scarves)
Not including McQueen in the official list is almost criminal. Same with Ann Demeulemeester.
 
did they really think that trussardi put out a stronger collection than alexander mcqueen?!

It feels as if Trussardi has just been thrown in to make the list look as if it's been thought about.

Some of these collections were alright, but being headed by Balenciaga, that first list I could happily paste into a 'most disappointing collections of the season' thread.
 
As predictable as a soap opera. I just wanna know, has Prada ever NOT been on this list? It's one thing to be paid to put a name on this list, but it's just foolish to think that people actually buy into it.
 
As predictable as a soap opera. I just wanna know, has Prada ever NOT been on this list? It's one thing to be paid to put a name on this list, but it's just foolish to think that people actually buy into it.

Surprisingly Prada has been omitted from the top 10 list several times.

S/S09
S/S10
F/W11
 
^ Yeah but that's like 3 times out of how many? But interesting to know anyway. Thanks.
 
i'm just sort of amused that there are only NINE brands listed here...
:p...

:innocent:...
 
^^ haha it's true! I haven't noticed it!

I'm really suprised Balenciaga takes the first place. I'm agree to the rest of the list.
 
People, here's the actual list (I have the magazine beside me when I am typing it out...)

1. Balenciaga
2. Lanvin
3. Prada
4. Givenchy
5. Proenza Schouler
6. Chanel
7. Christopher Kane
8. Trussardi
9. Jil Sander
10. Valentino

Christopher Kane was missed out from the thread starter's list... =)
 
Anyway here's my opinion...

I seriously wonder how did Balenciaga get to the top of the list... I am never a fan of the Nicolas Ghesquière for Balenciaga aesthetic. Not then, not now, not future. I tried on some of the clothes from previous seasons in a outlet sale (clothes from two to four seasons ago which were going for 90% discount), and... yes, I was tempted to buy not because of the design but only the price (SGD$3000 clothes going for SGD$100), as I wanted a few more pieces of luxury fashion in my wardrobe but I decided against it because they were so not wearable (a bright red patent looking vinyl jacket that has no lining and you can see all the seams and everything on the inside, and padded cropped jackets).

I finally know how did the clothes ended up selling at such a huge discount.

As for the rest of the list... Where's my McQueen and Louis Vuitton!? (I thought that Marc Jacob had put out a reasonably strong season for LV with that Stephford Wives aesthetic (I agree that it's a boring recurring theme for the past couple of seasons), but with a sweet tinge of pastel colour inside.

And I don't think that Givenchy deserves to be at No. 4... it's an okay collection, not specifically amazing, especially with that ruffles cutting that we have actually seen in the McQueen's Horn of Plenty collection... I did have a question when I saw the following looks coming down the runway...

00300m.jpg
00180m.jpg

(images from style.com)

Isn't it McQueen...?

00100m.jpg

(images from style.com)

Ok, maybe McQueen took it from somewhere else... I don't know.

But I loveeeeeee Lanvin's collection... It seems like Alber Elbaz was paying tribute to the man who wanted to groom him as his successor, Monsieur Yves saint Laurent.
 
seriously, christopher kane?! i love christopher kane and he's doing magic at versus and umit benan definitely remains a star-on-the-rise at trussardi....but HOW is there any comparison?????

between this....
00240m.jpg
00130m.jpg


and this....

00330m.jpg


(style.com)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top