Style.com's Top Ten F/W 07.08 Collections

[Spike413]

My major problem was Lanvin. It was one of the more disappointing shows this season imo.

Giambattista Valli is also a surprising choice because as a whole I thought the collection was hit or miss.

I definitly think Donna Karan got snubbed, that was her best collection in a long time, and Givenchy also deserved to be on the list.

 

[Squizree]

Like everyone I think Givenchy should be on the list, but they missed a lot of other designers...Roberto Cavalli, Christian Dior, Versace. And why the hell is Marc Jacobs there? Does he always have to be on the list? People keep calling Jacobs a "fashion icon", that's probably Vogue made him one.

 

[style_expert]

^ at least he didn't make it twice to list, like before

 

[Squizree]

^ Yeah last time was probably the worst season I've seen.

 

[bedtimestorynyc]

Zucca shoulda been there! it was the best collection for me! McQueen i loved too
agree about Nina Ricci and Jil Sander.

i was VERY disappointed with Jacobs and Balenciaga!

 

[Squizree]

And where is Burberry?? That show ruled this season. I think this list is all advertising.

 

[city girl]

hm i knew nina ricci would make the list..i'm not complaining though
agreed with galliano, balenciaga and ysl in a way
don't agree with lanvin ( ), g valli (ann d or someone more worthy could've replaced that) or marc jacobs
yes givenchy and alexander mcqueen should have made the list!

 

[stilettogirl84]

I must be the only person who thought the the Marc Jacobs collection rocked!

Of course I've hated all his collections for about three years, so I guess everyone who liked them before don't like the new look he's moved into

 

[xmodel citizen]

WTF? I don't think that G. Valli, MJ, YSL or Marni should be there. Marni? Lordy, sooooo off base! No Givenchy? What were they smoking when they compiled this list?

 

[KhaoticKharma]

Marc Jacobs (always on the list, but I like it this time)
Jil Sander
Proenza Schouler
Nina Ricci
John Galliano
and sort of Giambatistta Vali are the ones I agree with...

... and thats a whole lot more than usual.

 

[city girl]

WTF? I don't think that G. Valli, MJ, YSL or Marni should be there. Marni? Lordy, sooooo off base! No Givenchy? What were they smoking when they compiled this list?

oh i love marni! it's very urban or something. just what i think

 

[miss_pepa]

I think its an adequate list. I always find the style.com top tens to be quite political. Im glad to see John Galliano there, I think Im the only one who is pleased to see Nina Ricci up there!
I was surprised Versace and Givenchy didnt get a mention after style.com gave them such rave reveiws...?

 

[gia0202]

i think most of the colelctions picked had such strong concepts, very sculptural---- except for proenza and marc.
I thought maybe i would later be impressed by prada, but after seeing the collection in person, i left craving the bags, a f/w prada parka/trench thing---but none of the new stuff. in person it really looks like old lady swimsuits and undies---not futuristically girly and glam as the ads suggest. M&M deserved every penny.

i agree with most the pics

 

[it-boy's nature]

Giambattista Valli


not familiar to me, but i will definately have to check out this collection.

 

[Derin]

No Trovata?!? Naah just kidding, don't worry
Balenciaga was my personal favorite so I'm quite content about it. I don't think Lanvin really deserved it. And seems like one collection that's missing in the list is Burberry...

 

[Guessgirl96]

I wasnt sure about balenciaga at first but it really grew on me. I actually didnt like valli this season as much as most people. I think burberry prorsum should've been on the list though.

 

[doktor avalanche]

i think HOUSE OF HOLLAND and preen should have made the list.

 

[Squizree]

I dont think Vogue even covered HBouse of Holland, but it was a pretty funky show.

 

[masquerade]

i think HOUSE OF HOLLAND and preen should have made the list.

house of holland? i think you actually have to design something to be considered a designer

 

[AudiEC]

The list should be expected. I have few problems with it. Agree with Jil Sander, YSL, Ricci.

Balenciaga is a bit controversial, while I liked it, there was nothing innovative about it.

Marc Jacobs, while a traverse into unfamiliar territory, is nothing new for fashion, even to the point of being dated.

Proenza Schouler was one of the few decent New York collections, a distinction that should be recognized.

Glad to see Galliano back on the list. Not my favorite show, but there was a romance and novelty there, something that was missing from the shows this season.