For me, the first one is an example of how UK Elle's covers can be very indistinct, where the foreground and background exists on the same wavelength, and there's not much that stands out in the image itself.
It's saved by the white lettering, but imagine if that didn't exist. Also, I'm not fond of a "I've fallen and can't get up" pose on any cover.
The second one has more confidence and self-possession, and would probably look well as a subscribers cover, with fewer coverlines on the left.
I don't tend to have much to say about UK Elle - it's one of the big three fashion magazines in the country, but I haven't been compelled to buy an issue for years, aside from a one-off purchase of the October 2022 issue with Adele - and only because that was shared content from the American edition, so I was saving on the import price.