While far from a perfect debut, it's absolutely not worse than some of the stuff Donatella has shown during the last few years, which is what folks crying for her return and mentioning Gianni seem to be forgetting. Does anyone really think he would've loved all that went down the Versace runway ever since he passed, not to mention the H&M collab and the decision to sell the brand to MK?! Let's be real, a lot of the pieces here are closer to Gianni's earlier work and their old Versace Jeans Couture collections than Donatella's output has been for a while.
What Vitale has to fix is the way his clothes are shown: the styling, the casting (even though I wouldn't say it was entirely wrong), the location, the beauty choices - Versace is just not a brand that is credible in a "We are throwing a house party at a friend's place, drop by if you want" setting. Sure, make it believable for GenZ, but don't forget it's after all probably the Italian fashion brand with the most glamorous reputation and that needs to be represented.