Gigi is clearly improving. Still isn't there but is.
I don't she will ever by a supermodel. I think she can become a top model but not a super. Even tho, I have seen a lot of people think she is the closest we got to a supermodel currently because of social media and popularity.
The photos aren't as strong as it appears. You have a lot of editing in it. I think the second cover could be where she looks best. On first she looks kind of mad. And third, you have a lot of editing on it and photoshop.
I do think people find first one far more pleasing because of the colors of it, flowers (and the main focus of it. It's very centered on it and Gigi looks a bit like an extra) and them between logo. It has been a while since we saw some like this on the logo area, I think. Most of the covers today, logo area is very clean or you clearly see it.
Besides Gigi, I think it had a great team on it.
I am becoming more pleased with what Vogue CS is doing. I don't exactly like most of the work done today with this minimalist aesthetic or somewhat of Nordic influences. But I already was expecting more creativity coming from them, compared with Vogue Portugal.