Hilary Duff Vs Lindsay Lohan

[hollyslookingdry]

Just some examples. Feel free to post more and discuss!

Photos of Hilary:

Photos of Lindsay:

 

[purplelucrezia]

I vote for Paris Hilton.

 

[MJCouture]

Originally posted by purplelucrezia@Aug 6 2004, 11:04 PM
I vote for Paris Hilton.

[snapback]323939[/snapback]​

Moi aussi. LOL.


To be honest with you, I don't see a great big difference between Lohan and Duff's style. I think Duff is a less trashy, but over all they have the same LA teen look. Yawn.

 

[oceanharlot]

there should be a button for both are terrible...

 

[Spike413]

Honestly, they both have shi**y style. Hilary is just bland and teeny bopperish, very 'look how cute and cuddley I am in trends that are over for years'.....and Lindsay, can we say Paris In Training? Way too skimpy and sleezy for a girl her age..........me and my friends yell out the car window at girls dressed like her, things like 'What would your mother think you little tramp!!!'

 

[xclusive]

i didn't know Lohan smokes!! i used to like hilary more she's very pretty but Lindsay seems like more fun and mature, Duff is alittle too airheady and blonde

 

[hollyslookingdry]

I agree stylistically they're both pretty bland. But I've seen lots of discussion about the two girls seperately and was curious to see who people like better, or well in most cases, seem to hate less.

 

[meowmix]

I think Lohan's style is more p*rn star...while Duff's is more teeny star. I don't like either, but of the two I'd at least give Duff points for trying to look like something half-silicone, half-caked on makeup.

 

[Ärtan]

When it comes to style: Duff
When it comes to acting/singing: Lohan

 

[strawberry daiquiri]

Now there's a fight I'd like to see.

 

[poo]

Duff all the way. that lohan is such a trashy wh*re

 

[Purr]

at first sight lindsay looks wilder and sexier, whereas hillary looks like your typical innocent all american teen... so i choose lindsay

 

[VainJane]

I pretty much agree with everyone here
Duff is your average teeny-weeny-bopper who emits rays of 'Let's go shopping at Abercrombie & Fitch before cheerleading practice!'
While Lohan is your next Britney Spears-Christina Aguilera in-waiting who's probably either going to develop a drinking problem or have a sex-tape scandal.

Now as far as clothes go....
Lohan is more creative, but Duff dresses like someone who has enough confidence in herself to not feel the need to show everyone her breasts

I vote for Duff....make your mother proud girl

 

[SCBlondie]

Both are horrible in everything they do. Hillary Duff's movies have all sucked (at least the 2 I've seen) and Lindsay Lohan has been a 2-hit wonder (remember Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen? Niether do I) and her next movie is Herbie...

Can they sing? Seems like anyone can sing nowadays. Britney Spears still has a career (sort of). Niether of them act thier age. Lindsay acts like whatever age Paris Hilton is and Hillary Duff never left 12.

If you want to see an actual talented teenager check out Evan Rachel Wood.
http://cache.gettyimages.com/comp/3006290....C616F966FF61B87

I haven't really seen much of her style but what I've seen is pretty good.

Sorry for my rant.

 

[prixi]

I don't like either.

 

[mxggies]

i think that they both suck at choosing good outfits...and they're both chubby, but lindsay smokes...so hilary gets my vote

 

[hollyslookingdry]

Originally posted by mxggies@Aug 7 2004, 03:02 PM
i think that they both suck at choosing good outfits...and they're both chubby, but lindsay smokes...so hilary gets my vote

[snapback]324469[/snapback]​

If that's your idea of chubby then....wow. Hilary isn't chubby in any respects, and Lindsay's "chubbiness" is mostly the effect that large breasts have on an average body. I know girls at school whose bodies look chubby, when they're actually size 0s or 1s, all because of their large breasts.

 

[FashionVixen]

Originally posted by Ärtan@Aug 7 2004, 04:00 AM
When it comes to style: Duff
When it comes to acting/singing: Lohan

[snapback]324092[/snapback]​

Very much agree. Duff can't sing. Lohan looks like a wh*re. Difficult choice, but since Lohan smokes, I vote Duff.

 

[nycgirl84]

I think everyone agrees both their styles suck. That being said, based purely on their fashion choices, I pick Duff because we haven't seen her in a top with her large boosoms about to pop out and her belly protruding from under a cropped top -yet.

 

[PinkBeachBarbie]

I haven't voted yet, becasue I am not a fan of Hilary (nothing personal, she seems kinda bland), and Lindsay seems like she has a huge attitude problem (I mean I could be totally wrong , but I am sure her new found fame and all the attention she gets, has gone to her head!)

My Vote: Neither!