I don’t have the feeling that the Hawkings/Tom Ford situation is nowhere near the Valentino or YSL situation…
Hawkings was chosen by Tom.
He did his collection, Tom liked it but wanted more fashion, more of a strong statement.
He didn’t liked the narrative installed by Hawkings regarding the creation of Tom Ford menswear and that’s it.
The Tom/YSL situation was a lot more complicated, it had a financial layer as it was around the question of the acquisition of YSL.
Berge/YSL played the seduction game all before the acquisition happened. Ford presented the resort to them, then the show with Bergé in the attendance…
Domenico de Sole made comments regarding the way the house was handled financially and from there, it was war.
Valentino didn’t liked Facchinetti. He didn’t liked that she didn’t went to the archives…etc.
I don’t think Tom is that insecure.
After all, he made the decision to sell and chose his successor. He totally had the opportunity to promote someone from the womenswear team as a CD and Peter would have remained Menswear Design Director or something of that nature…
What I think maybe is that he should have handled his succession more smoothly. Maybe move the womenswear team and the menswear team together, have them work under his direction at least for 2 main seasons before giving the position to Hawkings.
Because obviously, he had a leadership in menswear and Tom Ford is a very much installed brand in the menswear arena but, it is still living under the glory of the legendary past for the womenswear part. And so his leadership was challenged there.
I think Peter tenure would have been fine but he would have never put Tom Ford in a place it could be.
And we saw it with Virginie. Her Chanel was a commercial success yes, but in terms of influence, fashion people didn’t wore Chanel as an It brand.
And it’s totally fair for a founder to expect his successor to do better than him.
Valentino under MCG and PPP was a commercial and critical success. Under PPP, the brand became part of the fashion conversation in a way that it wasn’t before…
they should look into hawkings for celine if hedi leaves. i think he will do well with continuing what hedi started and slowly developing it into his own like anthony for sl.
So this man is destined to follow someone’s path?
Even if the perspective of Celine as a name is appealing, it’s a bit reductive.
He is a connected person in the fashion industry and he is known. Most of the brands are Whitney’s clients anyway so I don’t have doubts about him having the opportunity to have his voice again.