Shoes: yay or nay? #1

[from: sophia]

Nay I would say yay if it had no heel and was just flat

 

[lottie342]

nay, they would look better with a much higher heel or just flat

 

[timemachinedream]

luluposh-nay, just because I feel like the heel is awkward.

 

[Velony]

I agree, I'd prefer them flat or with a higher heels so nay from me.

 

[John_M.]

Like in the "Yay or Nay?" thread, I missed a pair of shoes when I clicked on that "First New Post" icon. So let me comment on the oxfords in Post #11,057.

I'm going to give these a Nay! They'd be better if they were one of the following:
* a chunky low-heel, kitten heel, or flat
* a high-heel design without that spike heel
* perhaps as a wedge (low-heel or high-heel).

It's not outright hate, but these could be much better for me to really recommend them. So, nay. Sorry!

 

[STYLEOClDE]

Nay I would say yay if it had no heel and was just flat

i agree. it kind of looks a bit awkward with those
tiny heels.

 

[papa_levante]

Nay to luluposh

 

[pinkvogue]

luluposh-nay

 

[Florecita86]

luluposh - yay. I am actually the only one who likes them. I say, if you love them that much than buy them but if you feel that you do not want them all that much than do not buy them.

 

[luluposh]

Thank you for all the opinions I thought the short heel was quirky, but I guess most of you are right, it does look awkward and should either be flat, or higher. I shall skip on this pair..

 

[|BellaDonna|]

nay lulu plush

 

[Dego]

NAY to all kittenheels. Always.

 

[PinkPrincess113]

luluposh- nay

ebay.com

Pedro Garcia booties.

 

[rosalynn]

Not my style but I can totally see the appeal, so yay PinkPrincess113

 

[Legyviel]

nay to pedro garcia... looks awkward

 

[John_M.]

Time to help out PinkPrincess113 here...

I usually say that chic and rugged NEVER work. You know, NEVER try to merge a chic ankle boot with work boots in any attempt to look "cute." With these Pedro Garcia booties in Post #11,076, this looks like some kind of water boots or something, but given a serious dosage of chic as well as being made of [I'm guessing] suede. It does look like too much going on, but I actually think these are passable and cute. So I voted [Yay!] for Pedro Garcia's cute and funky ankle boots ("Napoleon Dynamite" spoof)! Too much going on, but it all strangely works. Either it's a pair of rain boots with a high heel and that back loop, or it's a pair of booties that think they are rain boots. Either way, I do like these. A little platform doesn't hurt either for these booties.

Yay is my decision.

 

[m.j.]

PinkPrincess113 yay, they are so cute, love the color! it will look great with jeans.

 

[Lamia]

PinkPrincess113-Yay!

 

[chaneladdict]

nay pink princess

 

[daggi]

sorry but nay