Sienna VS. Edie

[SiennaInLondon]

^^^^I love you! Finally someone with sense!

SIENNA STAY AT HOME AND GET NAKED LIKE FOR EVER!, only damn way no one is going to call you someone's copycat, oh well yes they would! She would be copying some Playboy girl...

Maybe people call her a copycat because no matter how many designers she wears, she always looks like she has raided Topshop trying to look like Kate or Edie or whomever. She always looks messy and her style is unconfident. People don't say things for no reason. I mean I can't think of another actress or model who has undergone so much censure. But then most people aren't idol worshipping schoolgirls who have managed to hit the big time.

 

[softgrey]

no ...
you're right sienna...

most people are idol worshipping schoolgirls who sit at home and bash sienna...

...

 

[Odette]

most people are idol worshipping schoolgirls who sit at home and bash sienna...

Really? Well I think is more stupid to critise a girl cause she copies Edie. I am a worshipping schoolgirl? Not really but at least I don't go round calling a woman I'll never meet copycat, what for?

 

[softgrey]

odette my dear....
i think you had a litttle trouble understanding my post...
i basically said what you are saying in yours...

i just said it in a different way....

 

[SiennaInLondon]

no ...
you're right sienna...

most people are idol worshipping schoolgirls who sit at home and bash sienna...

...

Who is being worshipped here softie darling ? The angel of anti-Sienna dom? Or is just an opinion? Forums are about opinions and lets face it, we are all sitting at home in front of a computer whether we have two posts or erm thirty-two thousand.

 

[lemeray]

No one can defend Sienna saying that she doesnt copy and has originality, she started copying Kate now Edie. Its proof that she loves to copy style icons.

Im just sick of all these teens and the media worshipping Sienna as the "IT girl" who started these trends.

 

[BohoChic]

Sure we are all opened to opinions and such but I find this whole Sienna bashing to get ridiculously over the top. Why all the hate for her? She is a successful career woman, doing what she loves best and also portraying one of her favorite icons in a movie. So what if she wants to dress like Edie or whatnot.

Its kind of getting boring how many people continously love to bring down Sienna for lord knows what. So what if she well known for being Jude Law's girlfriend, copying Kate blah blah....get over it already. We all copy the style of someone whom we admire don't act like ya'll have never done it. Just cause Sienna is in the public eye she gets more stick for it. And Sienna has been doing the boho look since 2003. NOT last year.

And about the Edie Vs Sienna thing, its has to be Edie since she started the whole boho chic look. Also in my mind I didn't picture Sienna to be honest, I really wanted Melissa George. Which is a shame really cause she looks so much like Edie.

 

[Mink]

hahahahaa I love this thread.

 

[coralmilk]

She's a young actress and many more experienced actors have discussed about how sometimes it's hard to start being yourself again after the film is complete, after the day is over because they spend so long playing a character. In Sienna's case I think she should have adopted her character at Alfie's style as it was much more convincing. Edie was a fashion icon in her own terms, ages ago and it's pretty silly to try and be like her 'cuz this totally the wrong decade for that. I know what I'm saying cuz I attended a school for three years where everyone looked like Janis goddamn Joplin. I'm always the one to admit that it's positive to draw influences from many places and people but to a certain extend that it doesn't affect yr own style. Does it really matter that Sienna is not very original? We all knew that Kate Moss was the greatest and we sure do know the true Edie so who cares about Sienna?

 

[Cola]

Um, isn't the American Scene look getting more popular all over the world now? Guess I can't wait to see Sienna in head-to-toe American Apparel and ironic thriftstore / "vintage" stuff

 

[Mink]

I think her copying has worn off now...

 

[Yanka]

well, its her against a dead girl. How can she lose?

 

[uberQuirkiness]

^^^^I love you! Finally someone with sense!

SIENNA STAY AT HOME AND GET NAKED LIKE FOR EVER!, only damn way no one is going to call you someone's copycat, oh well yes they would! She would be copying some Playboy girl...

haha absolutely hilarious and absolutely true! i think people bash sienna way too much. i love sienna AND edie AND kate.