The reason why some people are more responsive to salicylic acid or Benzoyl Peroxide is the because their skin type differences. If you have dry skin, and pimples are whiteheads, then salicylic acid is probably your better bet. But if your skin is oily, and pimples are like pustules, then Benzoyl Peroxide would be better. How do you know? Either you go to a Derm, or you can cross reserch and do it yourself (be careful though, honestly)
For anyone that have found Proactiv worked for them, here is the key:
Benzoyl Peroxide You need it!!! So if you stopped using Proactiv (like I did), then you can opt for a facewash with the Benzoyl Peroxide in it.
I have oily skin, and have had pimples for 3 years. But since I started this regime, my skin cleared up in 4 weeks. Now all I have left is a bit of scars which will fade. I don't know if this will help, but I will post it here. It is crucial that you need to follow it patiently. This is my 3 years worth of researching and experimenting.
What you essentially need (like I said, no need for money for clear skin, all the products here can be found at drugstore, but if you can find a brand that already work for you. Keep it, the key is the ingredient
_A
gentle cleanser. (dry skin: cetaphil. Oily skin: purpose)
_An acne cleanser. ( 2% Salicylic acid: there are TONs to choose from, but I like Neutrogena acne wash-the clear one. There is NOT that many Benzoyl Peroxide to choose from, the only one I can find is Neutrogena Acne Facecleanser/mask. It is 3.5% BP.
DON'T get anything that is 5% BP in facewash or more unless prescibed by your Derm or doctor.)
+the percentage matter: easy! higher %, higher chance of irritation. If you found a 2.5% or 2% and it is still irritating, lower it. If it's not clean enough, move it up. This usually applies to Salicylic Acid. Researchs have shown 2.5% BP works just as good as 10%, with less irritation. And this is just face wash.
_An acne cream. (SA or BP. Start out with 2.5% or 2%)
*****Guys, the reason I stress on the % is because most of you probably have trialed your skin under different acne treatments before. So it would be wise not to damage your skin any further.
_Moisturizer (of your choice, benefitial for your skin of course. There is no need for this moisturizer to have acne medicine)
Ok, here is how it works (for treament period, usually last 1 months. This needs to be followed for 2 weeks. Then if your skin cleared up a bit, you can go straight to longterm routine -which I will describe after)
Mornings, you wash with gentle cleanser, put on sunblock, you know the routine. (BTW, ALWAYS put on sunblock please!) But if you feel the need to increase strength of your regime (if you don't have sensitive skin of course), you can use the acne wash instead of gentle cleanser)
When you go home, take off your makeup IMMEDIATELY. I also advice avoiding wearing makeup as much as possible while you're in treatment. The Purpose Cleanser can also take off face makeup too. SO less money wasted.
At nights:
_You wash with Gentle Cleanser, so that your face is CLEAN. (For sensitive skin, please don't wash your face now with acne cleanser. Because you will put on medicine cream or gel later)
_Pat dry.
_ANd here is the key to countereact BP or SA's drying or irritating effects: A layer of 100% Aloe Vera gel. (fruits of the loom or generic brand of CVS is fine) (It is thin so the medicine can still be absorb through your skin. But it added a bit of moisture so you don't feel itchy all night)
_Put on BP or SA gel or cream. But don't rub it, put a layer over the infected AREA, not just spots. (Be a bit thicker than just a thin film. Especially over the big spots)
Go to bed darling, don't moisturize anything else on top of it. Your skin will need to peel so that the toxic skin is gone. THEN we will do the nourishment. Another thing is skin hygiene. Don't touch your face with hand unwashed. Tie you hair or somehow pull your hair away from your face while you sleep. I use the hair claw to pull my hair back AND UP, so I can still place my head comfortably on the pillow. heheh
_Two or three times a week, use a gentle exfoiliater to get rid of all the peeling skin. (I use pHisoderm gentle exfoliater. It is PH balance. and be gentle)
The thing is: your face will get WORSE before it get BETTER. You need to break out first, to get all impurities out of your pores and your toxic skin is gone. So be patient.
So, after most acne is gone, all you have left is a few. (or if your skin only has a bit acne to begin with, there is no need for you to go through treatment period) Now we start with normal day routine as I have mentioned. But night routine is different:
_You will alternating: You will still do the night routine of acne treament, but only for 3 or 4 nights a week. Every other night, you will cleanse your skin with acne cleanser (please don't leave it on under 30seconds. Don't leave it on for more than 60 seconds either) A toner if you want to. And do your normal moisturizer (or a treatment moisturizer). This way, there would always be a bit of BP or SA in your routine, to keep your skin clear. But now there would be time for nourishment of the skin.
I also do a simple facial once a week, no matter what. You can find directions for that on the internet. Or you can tell me if you want me to post it. I make my own masks. But I don't have time to post it now (time to go shopping hehehe). Maybe later if anyone need it.
I usually see ppl just say: use this product, this works, but they don't tell you specificly how to intergrate it in a routine or why it works. So please forgive me if this is too long for you to read.
I have sensitive skin, and most ppl will too if their skins are now raw after trying so many acne treatments. So I developed this routine for ppl with sensitive skin like me. You can change it a bit according to your skin, if your skin is signigficantly different. (ahh, but that's another post)
You should be patient. You should only stop if it causes you pain even if you lower the dose. I can't quarantee it will work. But it worked for me. I know how painful it can be to have acne, both physically and emotionally. So try it and let me know the results or what you think.