Their pop songs are awful in a fun way. But the heart of the Cure lies in their dark songs. Disintegration is one of the best albums of all time. "The Same Deep Water As You" has always been my favorite from that album, as well as the B-Sides "Too Late" and "Fear Of Ghosts". And "Untitled", "Prayers For Rain", "Plainsong", "Last Dance"...
I know the official Trilogy is p*rn*gr*phy, Disintegration, and Bloodflowers, but I think the real trilogy is Seventeen Seconds, Faith, and p*rn*gr*phy. They make more fluid sense together played back-to-back, musically and sonically. I understand the concept of calling the others the Trilogy, but playing those CDs back-to-back is rather jaunty with the huge changes in sound and musical style. The Trilogy Live DVD is a different matter, though. It's totally brilliant, and everything really gels in that experience.
I wish Robert had done what he originally intended with Wish and released it as a "two-faced" double album, one CD of the happy, poppy Cure, and the other of the dark, depressed Cure. That would have been brilliant. Damn record company pressure. But if you take dark Wish B-sides like "Play" and "This Twilight Garden" and combine them with the darker, sadder Wish tracks ("Apart", "To Wish Impossible Things", etc.) and the song "Burn" from the Crow soundtrack of the same era, you have an amazing dark Cure CD.
Okay, I'm done for now.