I sometimes complain about the fact that Nicole is part of US Vogue's "holy grail" of celebrity cover stars. I don't think anyone other than Gwyneth Paltrow (who is the epitome of what Anna and Co adore) has been featured on Vogue more in the past 10 years. Correct me if I'm wrong of course but I feel like a Kidman cover is generally expected every other year just about. I find that frequency a tad boring in that there are so many other models / actresses who would make for great cover material.
That said Nicole's covers are usually gorgeous. Her 2004 Irving Penn cover was simply put nothing short of perfection in my opinion and I think that is exactly how a celebrity cover should look. Unusual, elegant and devoid of extraneous text. It succeeds on all the levels where this cover fails. She's a beautiful woman but this dress (which I think is STUNNING on the runway, Stam wore the hell out of it) does not suit her. Her hair is messed up, we've got all this horrid text littering the cover. Ugh. Subpar.