Lite_Brite,If it were merely a result of sick culture ( I assume by that you mean "Western" culture since you seem to be American) then why is it that every culture in the world has many forms of body modification? From Africa, to Asia, to Oceania etc, every continent (and every region within each continent) has had it's own idea of beautification for centuries.
This is not to say that your opinion is completely invalid since there are people who impose their standards of beauty on others, which I agree is sick and shallow. And yes, many people want to change a physical feature because they feel insecure, but that is only human and for some the idea that one can possibly feel more secure in herself can be very worthwhile. Some people can find confidence in the traits they dislike over time which is commendable, others struggle fiercely to do so and in the end, hesitantly decide to try another option of body modification. And again, others have only a small, nearly unnoticeable "flaw" that they would like to change just for the sake of balance or based on their personal preferences.
I agree that body image can become a slippery slope for many of us, and I identify with some of the issues you have struggled with, but it is not ones place to judge what others do to their bodies, especially without knowing their personal journeys to that point. Many people dislike tattoos and find them unattractive, but we can be sure that, to a person that has been tattooed, this permanent mark has significance. The same can be said for most cosmetic surgery. On television we see drastic cases of addiction, and botched basement collagen treatments done by unqualified "surgeons", people getting treble-G sized implants just so they know they have the largest set in the world etc. But if one takes the time to look at a cosmetic surgery forum, most people are interested in rather conservative, finesse procedures. They worry about friends and family not recognising them but in the end are disappointed to see that most people never even notice a change until it is pointed out
. And of course you see a few who have undergone several surgeries, but most only undergo a primary, or at most one revision if they dislike how their surgery has settled after a year or so. More importantly, most come out of the procedure a bit happier.
I don't assume that this will change you opinion, and there is nothing wrong with that since it is clear that your opinion comes from a place of espousing and encouraging self acceptance
. But for me one thing that may also be paired with these ideas of self acceptance is acceptance of other grown people's choices. They may seem saddening to you, but if you try to put your self in the shoes of another maybe you can see how one or two small changes can be worthwhile to another. Even if it only means a small change physically it may reap a large change in another persons confidence.
These are just my thoughts on your commentary, although I don't agree with
all of your points, I see and respect the reasons why these opinions have come about.