Usually, the infighting amongst fashion people is of no interest to me. But, there’s just something about Carine and Emmanuelle’s fallout and the Sith-like apprentice-overthrowing-the-master scenario with these two that’s intriguingly epic in all its fashiondom rivalry/betrayal/meangirlness. If only someone could wrangle and conjure this high fashion tale of tales into a series. Because as a cautionary tale, once one has made it in as part of the fashion insider— one becomes rather… creepy. This attitude of perpetual, juvenile behaviour festering amongst an elite, privileged group; viewing so highly of themselves as highly-evolved with a sophisticated demeanour, but shows their true behaviour with petty squabbles and immature tantrums that’s no different than minimum-wage labourers fighting over meagre benefits. People are really all the same, and no amount of coveted, expensive and silly high fashion adornments will ever erase how cheap some will always be, underneath it all.
Anyway, supposed loathsome attitude/personality aside, whichever unfortunate label he’s infesting onto next will inevitably need to invest the millions to hype his meagre talent: Bloated celeb-castings for campaigns; advertorials in Asian fashion rags; features in other fashion rags etc etc to convince the casual fashion shopper to spend on more overpriced and tedious gimmickwear. No doubt it’ll be more crass oversized Dr. Seuss designs, with overblown logo/monogram/signature prints in the most obnoxious color-palette that can be seen miles away— and all having shorter shelf-date than lettuce. And if all of that doesn’t work, he’ll resort back to his Banana Republic separates that really is his foundation. And just like Raf, he’ll be allowed to plague and ruin a brand then move on to the next— just like locusts. Hopefully he can end up at Prada and him and Raf can implode the brand and finally put Prada out of its megacorporate misery.
The Carine and Emmanuelle story is rather simple to me. Those were 2 women who despite their very bourgeois upbringing were after all very different. And while it worked for several years, at some point it didn’t.
Emmanuelle came to Vogue after having being the EIC of 20 and and the Fashion Director of EIC of Mixte (I don’t remember what was her position there). So she had an ambition as a journalist working for publication.
Carine, if she wasn’t who she is and with her accolades already at that time, was a « popularity hire ». She was the most influential stylist of that time, who happened to have worked for Vogue US, Vogue Paris, ELLE and some others edgy publications.
Running a magazine wasn’t Carine’s ambition. But the opportunity presented itself and she accepted. God can only imagine sometimes the dramas in those offices with all those powerful women who were somehow equal. Yes Emmanuelle became a star when she started to style Chanel campaigns but essentially, MAS, Carine and EA were strong voices.
Carine got a pass for a lot of things that an EIC of a magazine like Vogue would have never done: she was still a consultant for Gucci and YSL under Tom, she styled Karl’s campaign for H&M, she did a collab for cashmere sweaters, she was a consultant for Riccardo…etc.
We all love Carine but it didn’t really read « serious editor ».
I think it was too much ego. Emmanuelle wanted the position, Carine was known to not spend a lot of time in the offices.
And behind Emmanuelle Little schemes with Romatet, I think Carine was maybe less enchanted by the perspective of spending time at Vogue.
So Emmanuelle finally got the job she wanted. Unfortunately, Anna Wintour ended the journey.
And to add insult to injury, it was almost shady to include Carine and not Emmanuelle in the Vogue World event.