Editorials with Similar Themes

[mikel]

^Okay, thank you

 

[FashionBoy86]

Vogue Italia October 2005




modopixaat
xpedro-tfs

&

Mag: ??
Ph: ??
Model: Josefina Montane

from: Elitechile.cl

 

[mikel]

OMG this is just not just a similar theme, this is blatant plagiarism!

good finf though.

 

[Annu]

^it is so weird, first pic even color of the dresses are same. Anja's ed is shooted by Miles Aldridge. Ed name is the Pure Wonder

 

[Annu]

Maybe slightly off topic but at least Miles Aldridge likes food and Anja.
That the Pure Wonder in Vogue Italia October 2005 and
The New York Times Style magazine living spring 2007. Trunk food I guess or then other pics are just cover outtakes.
(http://www.nytimes.com/)
Fashion editor: Anne Christensen. Set design by Stefan Beckman. Food styling by Susan Spungen.

 

[ganimedes]

Vogue UK December 2004
Pantomime by Tim Walker


scanned by Estella Mare / tfs

Para Ti Collections Spring Summer 08
China, Japón, media vuelta ¡y PON! by Miguel Esmoris


more: http://www.bwgreyscale.com/discussion_boards/viewtopic.php?t=12110
scanned by kokobombon / bwgreyscale

 

[makeupbuddha]

don't mess with Tim!

oh HELL no. Tim Walker is the best, how dare anyone try to emulate him. His style is so distinctive! I don't get it-if you like something enough to be inspired by it, why not respect the artist who created it? i think it's fine to be influenced by someone or even do your version of a similar theme, as long as you credit the person who inspired you. but to outright copy something this blatantly? lazy and lame.

 

[kasper!]

American theme--2 eds

#1 Vogue China July 2006
Photographer:Jason Schmidt
Stylist:Antja Winter
Models:Tatiana Usova & Milagros Schmoll



my snap

 

[kasper!]

#2 W magazine December 2008
American Dreamin'
Photographer:I nez van Lamsweerde & Vinoodh Matadin
Stylist: Alex White
Models: Lara Stone, Sessilee Lopez, Abbey Lee, Aline Weber, Eniko Mihalik






w magzine via shely

 

[kasper!]

continue..same source

​

i like the first ed....

 

[ganimedes]

Elle Italia August 2008
Lavori in Corso by Alexei Hay





scanned by Diciassette (17)

 

[ganimedes]

Elle Argentina March 2009
A toda maquina by Eduardo Martí



scanned by kokobombon

 

[XavierRaphael]

Somebody should just post EVERY Steven Klein from US Vogue. All his ed's are "Glossy-Barbie-Doll-Like-Skin".

 

[TREVOFASHIONISTO]

the eds w/ tanya
on th beach are also 1s 2 post

 

[VogueParisLover]

Vogue (US) March 2006 | "Strokes of Genius" | ph. Steven Meisel | models: Snejana, Sasha, Lily D | source: pivovarovist



Vogue (Italia) Sept 2005 Supplement | "Couture" | ph. Steven Meisel | models: Gemma, Eugenia, and ? |source: ilovegemmaward + eugeniavolodina.co.nr


These editorials aren't similar in terms of appearance, but they certainly share the same theme of painting, and both were shot by Meisel, so I feel they're still worth comparing. What I find most interesting is that the American Vogue version is much more tame. It has a lighter, more playful feel to it -- very appropriate for both the Spring season as well as the tamer, generally less avant garde nature of the publication itself. In contrast, the Vogue Italia version is edgier and grungier, definitely more suited to the Autumn season. I personally prefer the Vogue Italia, though I actually like both

I have one to add to that:
Vogue China June 2008 / "The Power of Art" / ph: Nick Haymes / model: Emma Pei / source: Aja Mok
I think it shares the same art theme.

 

[VogueParisLover]

slightly similar, I think.

AMERICANA
Dazed and Confused January 2008.
Photographed by Xevi Muntane
Styled by Karen Langley
Hair by Tomo Jidai at Jedroot
Makeup by Ayami Nishimura at Jedroot
Model: Alana Zimmer at Supreme.
source: posted by Karen Langley at dazeddigital.com

Numero 86
Photographed by Greg Kadel.
from theimagist.com

I have another to add to this one too!
Vogue Paris March 2009 / "Piece Maitresse" / ph: Karl Lagerfeld / models: Eva Herzigova & Claudia Schiffer / source: Diorette
Kind of cowboy, Americana.

 

[kasper!]

bright color theme

#1
Bazaar US February 2009
Photographer:Alexi Lubomirski
Fashion Editor:Aleksandra Woroniecka
Models:Siri Tollerod & Karmen Pedaru


[URL="http://img248.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=20160_siri_tollerod-baz-feb09-5_122_253lo.jpg"]
[/URL]
source:scanned by sister-d

 

[kasper!]

#2
Vogue UK February 1995
Photographer:Mario Testino
Fashion Editor:Lucinda Chambers
Models:Meghan Douglas and Yasmeen Gaurhi






source:scanned by PhilA

 

[vavavinny]

This is an EXCELLENT idea for a thread! I love it! There are so many overlapping editorials nowadays.

To go along with the food-themed edits, remember Natasha Poly shoving ice cream and sandwichs in her face in the December/January 2005 issue of VP? I think it was a tongue-in-cheek send-off to all of the people who were making a huge fuss about all of the thin models at the time.

 

[MulletProof]

This one's probably not similar by theme but quite a few of them. Don't hate me, I couldn't resist.


VOGUE ITALIA AUGUST 2009
Photographed by Tim Walker
Model: Georgia May Jagger
sources: models.com/streeters agency/ilovemuffins.es/blog.hudsonjeans.com

similar to..

Vogue Italia December 2008 & Vogue Paris March 2008


[source: herfamedgoodlooks/streeters/ilovemuffins.es]