Shoes: yay or nay? #1

[iLoveCouture]

lala - nay.

 

[WhitleyGilbert]

Thoughts please? They're suede. Steven by Steve Madden. $150

Amazon.com

 

[LAMALONE]

Whitley- yay

What about these?

http://www.stevemadden.com/item.aspx?id=47138

 

[from: sophia]

^Yay

 

[John_M.]

Time to play judge again... in the case of the pumps by Steve Madden (Post 9,165)...

...(I a fan of Steve Madden, but...) Nay! I'd be happy if there was just the ankle strap. I'd be happy if the extra straps went around the actual foot. I was inclined to say "Yay!" because of its style overall. The biggest aspect that makes these pumps a fail is this- they are suede. I'd love for the pumps to be of a shiny patent leather. I can't believe how many times I've said it for a guy who isn't crazy about this color, but I'd prefer them to be black.


Nice shoes, but the negatives outweigh the positives. So nay.

 

[m4ryb3ar]

whitley- yay
lamalone- nay

 

[Dali]

whitley- nay
lamalone - yay

 

[Echoes]

Thoughts please? They're suede. Steven by Steve Madden. $150

They'd be better without the lower strap around the heel.

What about these?

Nay.

 

[statonscarlet]

Whitley-Yay
LAMALONE- neither Nay or yay, they are either or for me.

 

[Jujuritinha]

Whitley and LAMALONE Nay! Both are way too expensive for a super cheap look!! Sorry

Don't get me wrong, I love low cost shoes but I specially like them when they look like they're worth more than what they cost and not the other way round!!

 

[WhitleyGilbert]

Thanks for your opinions everyone. They were helpful in luring me away from making the mistake in purchasing them. The nays were very persuasive and I'm not liking the shoes so much now. My credit card is happy. Thanks again.

 

[LAMALONE]

Thanks guys for your opinions. They are too expensive and they could look better.

 

[John_M.]

Again, I like the shoes from Post #9,165. Only that there were a number of problems that make them a fail to me. Either if they were a patent leather or velvet or something, I'd like them more. I don't like the color much either. Those sparkly details would explode in loveliness (to me) if they were black or red or something. Just a lovely shoe, but ultimately a fail. Maybe also if they were in the price range of $30 to $60 ($75 at the most) would have also helped.

You're welcome for the opinions. I'm just an opinionated Texas boy putting the 713 (and 281) on the tFS map. Bring on more shoes to judge!

 

[aris]

OK, Texas boy go ahead
Saks
Jimmi Choo

 

[sweet_n_simple]

http://www.tonybianco.com.au

 

[kate_is_goddess]

aris - nayish
sweet n simple - nay, the material looks cheap

 

[quijano]

sweet_n_simple - nay, it looks poorly made. sorry.

 

[rinck]

any opinions on these? i cant decide if they will tire of them quickly or if they are too "space agey"
http://www.endless.com/dp/B00112EJNU?tag=endlesscj-20&linkCode=asn&creativeASIN=B00112EJNU

 

[John_M.]

For the pumps in post #9,117...

...Yay! The details and the color are both pleasing to me. The design of the pumps are also very lovely to me as well. They'd be some pumps I'd wear if I were a femme. I'd find a nice pair of indigo blue bootcut jeans to wear with them or perhaps a crimson-colored dress. I like them. Don't love them, but like them a lot.



For the pumps in Post #9,118...

...Yay! There are very few wedges I don't like. This is kind of like a coffee (once you add creamer) color for the base part of the pumps. It's a cute pair of pumps. There are very few wedges I dislike, and this isn't one of them. Yay for me.



For the pumps in Post #9.181...

...Yay (moderately)! I don't really like the platform base of these shoes, but they still remain very nice shoes and really a good pair of pumps to wear if you're daring to wear platform pumps. They also come in white with the same black platform base, but the white color with this black base is a fail. So ultimately, these are shoes to yay! about.



So "Yay!" for all three pumps.

 

[from: sophia]

Rinck YAY those are amazing I would consider buying a pair and a good price at that