I'm not sure what size those boots (Post #9,679) run. I've honestly tried to find these to help answer your question, MissyJG. If we were comparing, I'd say Nay!. The Marc Jacobs boots everyone seemed to love? Obviously, I'm not in that crowd. I obviously didn't fall in love with these upon seeing these horrible abominations. Their shape is lovely, but these are hideous to me. If I had the choice between these and some other shoe, I know there are several more shoes in the shoe store or shoe section that would be worlds better than these. And what's with the little circles around the heel? They trying to be Converses or something? Horrible shoe. There are better boots in that shape that would be much better to me than these hiking boot-like, trying-to-be-chic, waste of money boots.