Shoes: yay or nay? #1

[nicestthing]

what do you think about these? i'm planning to buy them today but i'm not 100% sure whether I like them or not

black
http://www.topshop.com/webapp/wcs/s...category_rn=42358&productId=1146253&langId=-1

i want to buy them in black although photos of the orange ones are much better, so showing them as well
http://www.topshop.com/webapp/wcs/s...category_rn=42358&productId=1202211&langId=-1


yay or nay?

 

[Aradia-Renee]

Yay!

 

[caroulemapoule]

YAY! But only for the black ones

 

[rosalynn]

Yay nicestthing!

They're similar to a pair of Chloe ballet flats that I have. I'm super fussy with ballet flats too so that's quite a recommendation coming from me!!

 

[Lamia]

nicestthing,yay for the balck ones!

 

[John_M.]

Hope you all had a great weekend. Now, this is a chance for me to talk about the Minnie Flat Bow Ballet Shoe from Post #10,784. I'm going to Yay! those flats except for the huge bow at the front. You have my word on these flats. I'd get 'em! I'm more impartial to black than in orange.

 

[nicestthing]

Thank you guys!
Bought them yesterday night!

 

[nangnangnj]

Love them in black and orange.
If only they were real ferragamo for 28 pounds!

 

[Lovin_It]

Boca python flats?

http://www.neimanmarcus.com/store/catalog/prod.jhtml?itemId=prod47660032&eItemId=prod47660032&cmCat=search&searchType=SALE&parentId=cat980731&icid=&rte=%252Fsearch.jhtml%253FN%253D0%2526st%253Ds%2526Ntt%253Dpython%2526_requestid%253D6601

(redcued in the sale to $327 too )) )

 

[chicandcool]

I rarely like wedges but these are probably an exception

Seychelles Platform Wedge ($98) from UO

 

[ChrissyM]

yay i like those

 

[STYLEOClDE]

yay, me too.

 

[rosalynn]

Yay from me, although I do like wedges

 

[John_M.]

Been a while. Let's talk shoes again!


I'll begin with the flats in Post #10,792. To be honest, I've never liked pointed-toed flats, open-toe/peep-toe flats, or anything like that. The python design isn't all that pleasing. So I'm going to have to Nay! those flats, just not to a really severe degree.

From flats to platform wedges... The overall shape of these wedges are sweet. Those wedges are a Yay!, except for that little opening on the wedge part. Call me as someone who doesn't like something purely different, but I'm not real fond of any avant-garde (if you can call it that) style of the wedge with the little opening on the wedge part.



So there you are. Dress confidently!

 

[NutriGirl]

Hi all

Found this http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT&item=250423962232

I was really in love with these shoes last year when I first saw them on net-a-porter, but the price was way to crazy for me. So this is a good chance for me to get them... What do you think?

 

[rosalynn]

Sorry NutriGirl but a nay from me.

 

[daggi]

NutriGirl sorry but nay

 

[Legyviel]

nay to the python flats
yay to the wedges
and a slight nay to the fendi pumps but if you really love them, get them.

 

[pinkvogue]

yay to the python flats
yay to the wedges
nay to the fendi pumps

 

[John_M.]

Rarely do I dislike a pair of mary janes. But for the ones suggested in Post #10,799... not enough to yay these, so they're a (very slight) Nay! to me. The overall shape of the shoes are a killer for me as well as the heel design. You're probably better off looking for a similar pair of mary jane pumps. I'd probably look for a pair of high-heel mary jane pumps with a better overall design. Wedges are perfectly fine as are any regular high-heel pair of mary janes. If you're a bit daring, maybe find some with a nice peep-toe design. Or if you don't fancy mary janes at all, then a romantic pair of pumps with a lovely ankle wrap design would suffice.

These are a nay to me. Just more negatives than positives for those shoes. Make that five nay's in a row.