The Fashion Spot Top 50 Models F.K.A. Top 75 | Page 44 | the Fashion Spot
  • MODERATOR'S NOTE: Please can all of theFashionSpot's forum members remind themselves of the Forum Rules. Thank you.

The Fashion Spot Top 50 Models F.K.A. Top 75

Status
Not open for further replies.
yes, i counted campaigns. but I also counted runway and editorials. raquel did zero runway (well besides LV) and Isabeli did some.

Karmen was in the top 3 models when it came to runway, and she has numerous editorials from june to september... 12 to be exact. She was on 2 covers, got Michael Kors and the fragrance, and got the Fendi fragrance.

Jac was also in the top 3 models when it came to runway. Jac got 5 campaigns this past season, not one or two.

Liu had 5 campaigns, the Estee Lauder contract, a Numero China cover, 4 Vogue China editorials, an OG US Vogue ed, and she also did a ton of runway.

Karlie did a **** ton of runway (as usual), Dior Beauty, Dior Fragrance, Bally, ODLR, 3 US Vogue eds, a Vogue Italia ed, a Vogue Japan ed, and a HB Australia cover.


They all deserve their spots, IMO.
 
im sorry im not trying to be a pain in the butt,but i do not agree with the top 10

1.- Raquel (7 cam + 2 br,14 eds,shiseido contract,6 covers)
2.- Lara (CK exclusive,3 fragance deals,pirelli calendar,10 eds,Tom ford beauty,5 covers)
3.- Isabeli (7 campigns +1 br,6 eds,Este Lauder fragance,pirelli Calendar,5 covers)
4.- Arizona (8 campaigns,11 eds,2 covers)
5.- Liu Wen (4 eds,4 campaigns,2 covers, HL contract)
Constance ( 4eds,3 campaigns,3 covers, HL contract)
6.- Anja (6 eds,2 covers,6 campigns)
7.- Monika( 5 eds,5 campaigns,1 cover)
8.- Karlie (5 eds,4 campaigns,2 covers)
9.- Karmen (6 eds,2 covers+1 suscriber,1 campign,1 fragance)
 
i did not count runway because i think that is not important for stablished models(as you can see this season)

i think either raquel or lara can take the number on spot,just depends the way you see it.
Arizona at #1 cant be,sorry .8 campaigns,11 eds, only 2 covers,no fragance/beauty contract. it just do not compare to the top 3
Liu/ Constance pretty similar i couldnt choose between them.


pls tell me what u guys think or if i did something wrong
littlekiki i dont want you to think im rude or something,is just n observation i did n who know i might be wrong. ;)
 
ohh my looking at Joan she should be in top 10 too,tide with the EL girls or maybe higher

Joan (8eds,4 campaigns,2covers EL contract) no??
Freja ( 7eds,3 ads+ Br.,2 covers,1 fragance deal)
Sasha(4eds,4 campaigns,1 cover,1 fragance deal)
Natasha ( 5eds,3 covers,3 campaigns,Pirelli calendar)
 
no yeah i dont think runway is an important factor, and it seems as if that was the heaviest thing on your list
 
It was pretty much split down the middle... half runway, half everything else.


I value all of your opinions highly, so any advice is great. thank you :)
 
I worded that wrong... runway was a factor, but it wasn't half. For instance, Raquel was still able to get the number 2 spot without doing any runway besides LV.
 
I knew raquel was going to b number one n then isabeli,but counting lara some of you might think she is the number one.it really depends in the points that this list is based of.lets wait for rockangel list to see how well we did.^_^
I think joan n freja might made it to the top 10
sasha n natasha r pretty tide too.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
I think I see where Michael was coming from - don't think of this as a measure of a model's worth, but simply a breakdown of who booked the largest amount of work in the past season. Some of the scoring system might still need a little tweaking but I understand the 50/50 split of runway and other work since both are important for a model's career in different ways. The only other way I could see doing it would be a separate list for runway and print.
 
I don't know if "equal" weight to runway and campaign/cover is fair. Certainly getting only a few major campaigns can trump an entire season's worth of runway work for most models. The trend is for models to walk runway in order to raise their visibility for campaigns, which is sort of the end goal for most models. So weighing them equally is ultimately biases the list against more experienced campaign queens that elect to skip fashion week simply because they can afford to do so. It's not like they can't walk the catwalk, just that they choose not to and they have no need to.

I don't think you should exclude runway, of course, but reducing their weight in the formula may be a good idea.
 
I can lighten the weight of runway if you guys think it's a good idea :) Thanks for the suggestion.
 
:lol: well i dont know if you guys know,but there is a list of the points each work is worth it :)

im soo thankfull,u did it,but next time u can based the pioints from that list ;)

it is a really tireding workdoing this i only did like 10 models n it took me like 2 hrs!
 
Ok guys...could anybody help me collect the S/S12 runway-info for each model?...Add the runway of this season , has been a last-minute decision and I have not enough time due to work ... Thanks in advance:flower:....more details please PM =)
 
^Nevermind. I've decided to dispense with that information ... I'll start editing the pics...in a few days I'll post the finished list =)
 
I'm sorry, I had made the list in October last year, and wanted to edit the pics but this has been impossible because of my job:judje:. anyways, I could post the excel file(May to october). I wish could have more time to devote to this as it is fun. It's just too much work so I can't continue with the ranking:(. I hope littlekiki or another member will take over :) Good luck guys and enjoy:D

excel file-> here
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'll help someone out to do the list! I can't take the whole job on on my own but I can certainly help.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

New Posts

Forum Statistics

Threads
214,044
Messages
15,247,166
Members
88,051
Latest member
ritttch
Back
Top