I find Jack Davison's work pretentious, particularly in the context of fashion. There are moments of brilliance (Zendaya's W cover, for example), but overall it's very reliant on grain filters, tight closeups and props, like a photography student experimenting with his first film camera.
I don't know why Anna thought his work would be a good fit for US Vogue's basic and commercial vision of fashion, but the results are lacklustre. If this were the digital cover instead of Angelina's, I would give it a pass, but no.
She's better off sticking with her regulars like EJG, Tyler Mitchell and Annie etc. and Davison's talents are better suited to publications like Dazed, Self Service and M Le Monde.