i'm being lame and just chilling for new year's, but i feel you on the boston weather.
i think styling based off shoe choice is a good idea. as for the rest, my main requirement for new year's is a pair of pretty shu uemura false lashes!
i've been blessed with long thick eyelashes so a quick swipe of mascara will do the trick for me...

i think false eyelashes would make me look like a monster
i think i've decided on a body conscious blk dress with a sort of scoop neck and puff sleeve (also 3/4 length sleeve) from zara...
with a blk and silver diamond pattern belt, also from zara a while back..
thin material but i will be layering up...
with blk tights, blk slouchy boots
mustard/saffron rodarte for target cardigan and a short sleeved long cashmere michael kors cardigan on top of that...
will try to post a pic...
not sure if that all makes sense but i think it will work
also the requisite scarf, gloves and coat....
i actually have a yellow sort of bubble coat that my sister got me for christmas that i would love to wear out but i think it might not be a good match for the weather

we'll see if i decide to suffer for fashion tonight...