yes, I think the purple suede does suit the shoe much better. They are incredibly comfortable, and the proportions are great. I suppose I've just been frustrated because everything I have tried on has been of a lighter fabric (due to the season, and partially due to boho invading every corner, of any store that I can afford). I found an rich, emerald green dress that I could have possibly pulled off... if it weren't for the fabric. It was a light, billowy dress, and I felt that the shoe just weighted the whole thing down too much. I suppose I'll get more use out of them in the beggining of fall, when I wear more structured fabrics.
I just get so antsy when I buy new shoes! If I didn't look strange, I'd put them on directly after I paid for them. Right at the register.