I think Polina has gotten the most "votes" so far, and I wholeheartedly agree. Just as some models can pull off any style and design of clothing (I don't think she is one of them), Polina can pull off any makeup look, from dramatic to minimal, retro to modern, avant-garde to trendy, supertan to ice-princess.
I think it's because she has neither too strong nor fragile features, medium-toned coloring, and wide-spaces between her features (for example, lots of space between her eyes and eyebrows), which shows off the texture and color of makeup. And her face is expressive, and her eyes are warm. She looks natural both smiling and serious.
I think Caroline Wijnberg would also be fantastic if ONLY her coloring wasn't so delicate. A lot of makeup looks are very garish on her.