Yay or Nay? (November 2003 - June 2009)

[hautechild]

loverunway - nay. Topshop's designer ripoffs are ridiculous.

 

[moniescloset]

i say yay to the jacket and top. Although i don't know how much they cost, and thats always a big factor.

 

[John_M.]

A jacket and a dress. Let's get it on.

I'm going to Yay! the jacket in Post #12,426. Fairly simple jacket, yet pretty nice. That jacket is a win. Now for the dress in Post #12,439. To be honest... I'm going to have to fail (Nay!) this dress. It's not so much the designs, but the designs + the overall design of the dress. Sorry, that's a fail dress. You can look for a dress that doesn't have as horrid designs on it, as well as a dress styled a lot nicer than that.



Yay jacket, nay dress. Dress with confidence and show some style (whatever you consider stylish)!

 

[ChrissyM]

yay to both the jacket and dress on this page

 

[pinkvogue]

warningrhcp-yay
velony-yay
loverunway-yay

 

[STYLEOClDE]

yay to everything on this page.

 

[Legyviel]

Yay to the UO denim jacket
Yay to the topshop dress!

 

[warningrhcp]

Yay to the topshop dress and to the jacket!

 

[dcrd]

Yay to both!

 

[loverunway]

@ John_M - I don't understand what you mean when you say:

It's not so much the designs, but the designs + the overall design of the dress.

?

 

[flyme2themoon]

Velony - Yay
Loverunway - Yay

 

[gossiping]

yay to the jacket! and sorry but nay to the dress

 

[princess sparkle]

yay to the jacket and the dress!

 

[Aradia-Renee]

I love the dress, but then again I am a guy... It is smokin' to put it mildly... I like the designs also. YAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[ChrissyM]

@ John_M - I don't understand what you mean when you say:

It's not so much the designs, but the designs + the overall design of the dress.

?

i think he means the raised zig zags when he says the first "designs"
pattern or print might have been a better way to describe it but even those words aren't entirely accurate...

 

[WhitleyGilbert]

Thoughts on this maxi dress please:

FrenchConnection.com

 

[loverunway]

whitleygilbert- that is really gorgeous for a maxi dress but I just can't like maxi dresses as very few people can pull them off. Still, it's really pretty so yay.

 

[warningrhcp]

Yay to the dress, it's very pretty.

 

[ChanelLove]

YSL.com

Yay or Nay?

I can also save a little more for the Chanel Shopping Bag:

eBay.com

 

[á la Balenciaga]

yay for the maxi dress!

yay for the ysl bag.

nay for the chanel bag. (too many fakes, you'll just blend in with then rest)