I fail to see any connection between this and Rodarte...
The same girl may enjoy the aesthetic of both houses, but that is where the comparisons end. I wouldn't even put Phi in the same boat as this. It's quite insulting, really...
If we all thought about fashion in such a basic, demoralizing sense, it would not be what it is today. We would not have the people at the forefront, the very people influencing and inspiring individuals such as Marc Jacobs and the like. All we'd have is mediocrity and banality. Who dictates what the 'real world' is exactly? A magazine? Business reports? Also, what is a 'real' consumer?? That makes no sense; sounds like nothing more than a blanket statement. You may enjoy Erin Wasson's aesthetic but that does not mean everyone around the world is eating it up, no questions asked.
Idk any truly stylish ppl. taking cues from these silver-spoon sheep you seem to cherish so dearly. It would be silly of me to deny their influence, but it's rather ridiculous to believe that everything going on in 'real fashion' is due to some photos taken at one party or another.
Anyhow, as you said, you and I are two drastically different people. This is a very good thing. I will agree to disagree with you and respectfully so...