Tried and loved:
Dermalogica Daily Exfoliant
Dermalogica Dermal Clay Cleanser
Desert Essence Thoroughly Clean Face Wash w/ Tea Tree & Awapuhi
Dr. Bronner's Liquid Castile/Hemp oil soap, Lavender
Fresh Soy Cleanser ($$)
Lush Angels on Bare Skin
St. Ives Apricot Radiance
The Dermalogica is pricey, but lasts forever, so it's not so bad costwise. The Fresh Soy is really too expensive for what you get, but it's great for cleansing and removing makeup in one fell swoop. I always read how terrible soap is for your skin, but I love Dr. Bronner's and the Desert Essence. Cheap and clean and good.