I know very little about the film "Eyes Wide Shut." All the hype, controversy, and film in general happened when I was a bit young.
In other news, I finally say "Atonement" after not seeing it all when it was in limited release in theatres. I enjoyed it but some parts left me feeling a bit empty, if that makes any sense. I think it's because the book was written in third person pov, with different perspectives. A lot more is said about the characters and their motivations and feelings in the book. You get inside Cecila's head (a little anyway), Briony's, Robbie's, and even the girls' mother and Paul Marshall. Of course, it's understandable-if something with that many perspectives gets made into a film, a screenwriter and director would have to pick a story and kind of go with it.
So they followed the three parts-the first day, the war, and then Briony's confrontation. So in my head it's kind of like: Briony, Robbie, and then back to Briony again. But at the end of the day, it's Briony's story and the movie goes along with that idea more than the book did. I think if I hadn't read the book and just seen the film, I wouldn't even have noticed. Like I said earlier though, it makes complete sense and I did love the film.
Joe did an amazing job and I think he and the same cinamatographer should do more films together. It had the same roaming, long shots as Pride and Prejudice but they were able to make it a lot darker and fit the context of the film. Certain camerwork was a bit more jerky, indicating a handheld camera probably. The long five minute shot at Dunkirk with not cuts was amazing and I loved watching the special features to see how they did it.
The acting was pretty decent-it's hard for me to say. I think I remember reading they wanted it reflect the actual acting from the time period and I don't know a lot about it. But James was amazing and seeing him break down was fun to watch. Saorise (sp) was wonderful and Keira was pretty good as well-I think Joe really helped her in Pride and Prejudice so I can't really complain about that.
Sorry for the long post. I've been waiting to see the movie for months and I finally got to. That and the fact that I haven't been in this forum for months. It's great to see other peoples' opinions and I've got a whole new batch of movies to see after reading through.