The September Issue : A Vogue / Anna Wintour Documentary

Just saw it....And I did like it. But it's hard to believe it will be that successful. Mostly because Anna remained inside her shell completely and still did not offer up some more entertaining b*tch antics. So the take home message is that this woman is driven by, first and foremost, a strong business sense and an iron will to push forward fashion's place in the world. It makes good business, but is, unsurprisingly, not entertaining.

And my heart broke when she discarded the all-Galliano shot from the 20s editorial. It was so exquisite, perhaps it would have been the best shot from 2007 coming from American Vogue. Her reasoning appeared to be that there was already enough Galliano in the editorial. So either that was just an excuse to cut an image she really disliked, or she simply prioritizes the art so little that she almost worries that one glorious shot with Galliano dresses that far outshines all the other shots in the bunch would make the other designers jealous somehow.....Or she doesn't communicate properly with Grace what her motives are. On the other hand, you would think with this tendency to want to honor each designer equally, Grace could work out the permutations to get the best pics with an acceptable combination of garmets.

Something has happened with the image selection that is different from the 60s and 70s. On those rare occasions when I have seen the unpublished shots from a shoot, it has always been the photographically superior photos that have been published.

It's frankly disgusting to see photographic masterpieces be thrown out not so much on account of business, because naturally the magazine would sell just as well with these in print, but because of petty ideas about which designers *must* be represented in each editorial. And instead of that spread that would have delighted and inspired so many, we got another two pages of Caroline Trentini jumping around....
 
I saw it tonight, the theater was surprisingly crowded...I think Anna's most vulnerable moment was when she was discussing her siblings and how they may look down on her.

Grace's passion for editorials was great to see, but she probably belongs at W since they don't seem to cut as much as Vogue and also take more risks. I think the 20's shoot being downsized was rough considering it was incredible and it also showed how commercial Vogue has to be, which is unfortunate.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They cut out the two page Galliano shot for two pages of Caroline with the "right clothes". How is that commercial?

Being commercial as in selling to the masses is merely the issue with the covers....

The choice of images for eds is another matter entirely....that's business favors...
 
They cut out the two page Galliano shot for two pages of Caroline with the "right clothes". How is that commercial?

Being commercial as in selling to the masses is merely the issue with the covers....

The choice of images for eds is another matter entirely....that's business favors...

It's more than the covers, they seemed to cut out any artistic shots (The 20's shoot was the most "daring" and it got the ax the hardest)...the whole issue clearly has to be commercialized. It needs to translate easily for someone flipping through it in a supermarket.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Can someone who already saw the documentary tell me the story behind the I&V shoot with Lily and Raquel and why it was killed in it's entierety.

And also the story behind the killed ed with Hilary and Chanel?
 
ugh it's only playing in like, 4 cinemas in london! and non central. what the hell.
 
^it's a movie about Vogue !

what did you expect ? a spread-all-over the world like Spiderman or Harry Potter ? Seriously !
 
I know I've said it a lot already, but the dvd is out on the 21st in the UK, so if you're Region 2 aswell, it's going to be one of the easiest ways to see the movie. We're really lucky to be getting the DVD so soon here, so I guess we can't really complain about the movie not being shown widely.
 
And also the story behind the killed ed with Hilary and Chanel?

There was no real explanation given that I remember, Anna just didn't like their shots and they got cut. It's funny they mentioned them by name so I was thinking they both just looked out of place. :shock:
 
^Thanks for the info. Is it shown who shot the pictures?
 
^^ When I initially saw that this outtake on A&C a year ago I was so livid...I cannot for the life of me understand why Anna cut it, her motives (I haven't seen the film) seem to be fairly irrational. The only thing I would say is that maybe the rest of the editorial content of the magazine would've looked limp next to this picture,

hfgl via her Steven Meisel board :heart:

That image, while stunning, would have been redundant but in a very specific way. If you recall, it was one of Anna's "dreams" to put together a Thanksgiving/holiday meal themed photo. Meisel met her vision with a group shot in his "Feast for the Eyes" editorial (1996 I think). It was an epic photo and I was surprised at how much it resembles the new outtake. Maybe the image was too similar for Anna's comfort as well. It's one thing to repeat generic poses and outfits, but quite another to repeat a dreamy, outdoor picnic couture shot.
 
when the dvd its out in US?...
 
^it's a movie about Vogue !

what did you expect ? a spread-all-over the world like Spiderman or Harry Potter ? Seriously !

forget what I said ....

I don't know if this is the complete list that I found ... But for the moment, the movie is screened in 10 cinemas ...... in whole France !!!!
a shame ! - though I guess it's good for only a documentary ... but who made it at Deauville, I expected at least 1 screenings in most of the biggest city of France (Marseille, Toulouse, Rennes, Nantes etc.)

4 screenings in Paris, 1 in Montpellier, Bordeaux, Angers, Strasbourg, Grenoble and Lyon
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I saw it tonight, the theater was surprisingly crowded...I think Anna's most vulnerable moment was when she was discussing her siblings and how they may look down on her.
Absolutely agree. She didn't open the floodgates or anything, but that little bit completely humanized her in my eyes. I mean I think we all assumed that Anna had feelings hidden behind those sunglasses, but it was nice to see them.

I think the best part was seeing the dynamic between Anna and Grace. I don't know if it's that Grace isn't easily intimidated or if she's just confident enough in what she does to stand up for it, but she was really the only employee who didn't seem to turn into a nervous wreck when Anna questioned her work. That's probably why there's a mutual respect there.

And all I can say about the cover is poor Sienna. :ninja:
 
Can't wait to see this!
 
I think the best part was seeing the dynamic between Anna and Grace. I don't know if it's that Grace isn't easily intimidated or if she's just confident enough in what she does to stand up for it, but she was really the only employee who didn't seem to turn into a nervous wreck when Anna questioned her work. That's probably why there's a mutual respect there.

I think a part of it, with Anna and Grace, is that they've known each other a long time. And Grace doesn't seem like the kind of person who would be intimidated, she's confident in her own opinions, although I guess resigned that she sometimes doesn't get her way. I can't imagine Grace being scared by Anna, and it makes me like her all the more.

I was very surprised it didn't get a wider release in London too though.
 
4 screenings in Paris, 1 in Montpellier, Bordeaux, Angers, Strasbourg, Grenoble and Lyon

So glad I moved to Paris :lol: I'm gonna see it in a couple of hours, hopefully it won't be a let down!
 
so suprisingly it played at a theater near me, it was exactly what the title says it is nothing more nothing less. i do wish it was longer. i dragged my mother with me to see it and it was us 2 and about 6 other people in the theater and it was opening night lol, but i expected that.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

New Posts

Forum Statistics

Threads
212,589
Messages
15,190,240
Members
86,487
Latest member
Fotchygirl
Back
Top
monitoring_string = "058526dd2635cb6818386bfd373b82a4"
<-- Admiral -->