Shoes: Yay or Nay? #3

[luckyme]

wawaweewha, the black suede ones on the bottom i like.

 

[shaq91]

What do you think of these???
http://www.kohls.com/kohlsStore/shoes/bootsnew/womensboots/overtheknee1/PRD~673735/Simply+Vera+Vera+Wang+Miro+OverTheKnee+Boots.jsp

 

[MissyJG]

^Yay if it weren't for the leather. It looks a bit cheap..

wawawee, I like the 2nd one from H&M beter.

Nay to the ASOS shoes and Yay to the brown men shoes.

 

[Dali]

^^ nay

 

[Mignonne]

nay too

 

[MartiniKiss]

shaq91 , nay

 

[MissyJG]

These pumps? Not sure bout the heel..

zara

 

[heroesofcouture]

MissyJG Yay from me. I love the slenderness at the front and the chunky heel.

 

[MartiniKiss]

MissyJG - yay

 

[Dali]

MissyJG - yay

 

[Dego]

MissyJG - nay, heel to thick.

 

[iLoveCouture]

Missy -

I dont like the heel, but I like them on the model with that outfit.

 

[John_M.]

Until I see a pair of over-the-knee boots I actually like, always nay over-the-knee boots. As for those Vera Wang high-heel ones (Post #522), Big Nay! I don't get the point or style of over-the-knee boots. I still have yet to get over them.

The pumps in Post #527 are going to get a (moderate) Nay! from me. If they were designed better, I'd show some love for these. The proportions just seem very odd for me to like these. I would have preferred a slight platform with rounded toes. With better design, I'd approve them. Since they aren't however, I'm failing those pumps.


Big Nay over-knee boots, moderate nay pumps.

 

[lightningfields]

^ I wouldn't buy boots that high for $109. They seem really cheap.

 

[amydang]

I like them a lot! The chunkiness is unique but I agree with lightningfields, $109 doesnt seem enough for a quality boot.

 

[John_M.]

I (if I were a femme) wouldn't buy those over-the-knee high heel boots for $1.09 USD, let alone $109 USD. They're still ugly to me regardless of the price.

 

[blackcoffee]

can't decide which ones... what do you guys think?

asos.com

laredoute.at

 

[Psylocke]

LaRedoute's shoes can become such an obsession, no?
I'm not a fan of the first pair because of that sock thing, so Nay! to the first and Yay! to the second pair.

 

[|BellaDonna|]

Blackcoffee nay to both... can't really articulate why, sorry

 

[John_M.]

Yay or nay and which... for the boots in Post #537. I'm going to go (very slight) Nay! for the first boots and and Yay! for the second pair. So I'd obviously go with the second pair based on my opinion. The second boots' color is a nice determining factor for me picking those. Those are cowboy-like boots that are quite cute. I am normally impartial to a hot pair of shooties, but these ankle boots look darling to me. Not overly beautiful, but I'd take the second ones over the first ones almost easily.