Phuel
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2010
- Messages
- 5,726
- Reaction score
- 8,722
Someone upthread mentioned that it feels (and looks) like Edward's last stint W, and that’s exactly how this is. Very disappointing for an unofficial inaugural of a publication that needed new vision and spirit.
The 70s-vibe of the cover that I had hoped would be a predominate tone seems to just be random… There’s no sense of that 70s-flair in the rest of the stories at all. Thee’s no flow— just directionless and all over the place— like W. Adwoa looks great of course— but I’ve always thought she was unusually gorgeous; her shoot is just Meisel going through his usual motions, which means copying Avedon. It’s nice… and also totally forgettable.
So far, it’s another W— with the hyped promise of diversity, of which I hope he really does bring with models of all ethnicities, not just Black models, as well as model of various ages. At least then, it’s something different than W.
(I have no idea why anyone would want to spend £75 for a signed hardcover of such mediocrity…)
The 70s-vibe of the cover that I had hoped would be a predominate tone seems to just be random… There’s no sense of that 70s-flair in the rest of the stories at all. Thee’s no flow— just directionless and all over the place— like W. Adwoa looks great of course— but I’ve always thought she was unusually gorgeous; her shoot is just Meisel going through his usual motions, which means copying Avedon. It’s nice… and also totally forgettable.
So far, it’s another W— with the hyped promise of diversity, of which I hope he really does bring with models of all ethnicities, not just Black models, as well as model of various ages. At least then, it’s something different than W.
(I have no idea why anyone would want to spend £75 for a signed hardcover of such mediocrity…)