W Magazine March 2008 : Scarlett Johansson & Natalie Portman by Steven Klein

[honeyisle]

They both look great. Scarlett's mouth is just a little to stiff, that's all.

 

[Tinsley V]

This has probably been said a thousand times... but

Why is there a dog on the cover....

 

[Alien Sex Friend]

Its an alive bag
and why are these dogs always in hands of all"posh" women?
in clubs. boutiques etc? did you asked `em? that looks much more stupid than a dog on the cover

 

[Miss Dalloway]

^^^ Thank you,dont get why Scarletts dog on the cover,is such an odd thing to see,like it was never done before.

 

[strawberry daiquiri]

this has convinced me even further than scarlett cannot act, or possibly even express anything with her face. I wonder if she demands to wear clothes that don't fit her, as well as that her dog be there.

natalie looks very good.

 

[SugarMe]

It's no surprise that Natalie Portman was discovered by a Revlon scout who attempted to get her to pursue modeling. If she was 5'10 instead of 5'2, I really think that she could have had a great career. At least she turned out to be a good actress.

 

[Vkid123]

Oh Natalie! She looks stunning! Scarlett and the dog look ok, I guess.

 

[happytrail]

scarlett looks so much like naomi watts there. kinda ruined the cover for me, but then again, i really don't like scarlett much anymore.

natalie though looks gorgeous!

 

[Mchunu]

i think this would have come off very nicely without actresses
the idea is good. the pooch with actresses is what makes it look, as someone said, "paris & nicole".

 

[OriginalSin]

Scarlett looks like a deer caught in a headlight in every pic.

I adore Scarlett but I'm inclined to agree. It's so disappointing that she looks shocked in every one of her pics especially since I feel she generally photographs really well. And she did that edgy shoot with Dita Von Teese a couple of years ago that was sort of dark, so I would've expected her to pull off this look better, but she just couldn't get it together here unfortunately

 

[softgrey]

i really love the styling...

 

[adorefaith]

i love the ellen page feature..

natalie looks great in the pictures..so authentic..

scarlett on the other hand..unfortunately...looks so self conscious + false..
and what is going on with her mouth?..she has such great lips..and they look terrible..

 

[Common_1031]

OMG what is up with Scarlett in these shots....its the worse i've ever seen of her...did she hear some bad news?

 

[cette fille]

love the clothes, but the dog kinda ruins it...

 

[alix*]

I can't believe Scarlett... she looks quite awful
Natalie looks great in all the shots.

 

[wheneveriwakeup]

The styling is such a provocation, I think...
I actually like the use of the dog...
Further promotes the lolita-theme...

Natalie photographs so incredibly well...
IRL she is adorable, imo...
But in photos she is so elegant, powerful, and alluring...

I am wondering if Scarlett's poses are intentional...?
She never photographs amazingly well, but never this bad, either...

 

[lunabella]

i LOVE this cover. the make-up, the clothes, so edgy!
i think this is the best celebrity cover i've seen. these girls, besides angelina jolie are the only ones i'd want to see on the cover of a fashion mag.

 

[chanelgurl]

maybe the placement of the chihuahua in there is a mockery to paris and nicole?

 

[Sabrina]

Scarlett looks like a Swiss milk maid next to Natalie in the cover shot...

 

[Drusilla_]

This'd have been a good cover if it was just Natalie..I appreciate them trying to go in a new direction with Scarlett's makeup, but with that expression the lipstick really doesn't suit her. Maybe if they'd covered up the cleavage and lost the rat-sized dog, it might have worked..