W Magazine March 2008 : Scarlett Johansson & Natalie Portman by Steven Klein | Page 5 | the Fashion Spot

W Magazine March 2008 : Scarlett Johansson & Natalie Portman by Steven Klein

They both look great. Scarlett's mouth is just a little to stiff, that's all.
 
This has probably been said a thousand times... but

Why is there a dog on the cover....
 
Its an alive bag
and why are these dogs always in hands of all"posh" women?
in clubs. boutiques etc? did you asked `em? that looks much more stupid than a dog on the cover
 
^^^ Thank you:lol:,dont get why Scarletts dog on the cover,is such an odd thing to see,like it was never done before.
 
this has convinced me even further than scarlett cannot act, or possibly even express anything with her face. I wonder if she demands to wear clothes that don't fit her, as well as that her dog be there.

natalie looks very good.
 
It's no surprise that Natalie Portman was discovered by a Revlon scout who attempted to get her to pursue modeling. If she was 5'10 instead of 5'2, I really think that she could have had a great career. At least she turned out to be a good actress.
 
Oh Natalie! She looks stunning! Scarlett and the dog look ok, I guess.
 
scarlett looks so much like naomi watts there. kinda ruined the cover for me, but then again, i really don't like scarlett much anymore.

natalie though looks gorgeous!
 
i think this would have come off very nicely without actresses :bounce:
the idea is good. the pooch with actresses is what makes it look, as someone said, "paris & nicole".
 
Scarlett looks like a deer caught in a headlight in every pic.

I adore Scarlett but I'm inclined to agree. It's so disappointing that she looks shocked in every one of her pics especially since I feel she generally photographs really well. And she did that edgy shoot with Dita Von Teese a couple of years ago that was sort of dark, so I would've expected her to pull off this look better, but she just couldn't get it together here unfortunately :(
 
i love the ellen page feature..:heart:

natalie looks great in the pictures..so authentic..

scarlett on the other hand..unfortunately...looks so self conscious + false..
and what is going on with her mouth?..she has such great lips..and they look terrible..
 
OMG what is up with Scarlett in these shots....its the worse i've ever seen of her...did she hear some bad news?
 
I can't believe Scarlett... she looks quite awful :doh:
Natalie looks great in all the shots.
 
The styling is such a provocation, I think... :woot:
I actually like the use of the dog...
Further promotes the lolita-theme...

Natalie photographs so incredibly well...
IRL she is adorable, imo...
But in photos she is so elegant, powerful, and alluring...

I am wondering if Scarlett's poses are intentional...? :ermm:
She never photographs amazingly well, but never this bad, either...
 
i LOVE this cover. the make-up, the clothes, so edgy!
i think this is the best celebrity cover i've seen. these girls, besides angelina jolie are the only ones i'd want to see on the cover of a fashion mag.
 
Scarlett looks like a Swiss milk maid next to Natalie in the cover shot... :innocent:
 
This'd have been a good cover if it was just Natalie..I appreciate them trying to go in a new direction with Scarlett's makeup, but with that expression the lipstick really doesn't suit her. Maybe if they'd covered up the cleavage and lost the rat-sized dog, it might have worked..
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Forum Statistics

Threads
215,220
Messages
15,291,798
Members
89,153
Latest member
mahanmhn
Back
Top