Well I'll say this, this is probably the most erotic thing Pilati has done since he took over at YSL, so props for that. And Jourdan is looking like quite the seductress. Whoever said succubi wasn't far off the mark.
As for Vincent, I actually do think there's something very attractive about him, and if he's good enough for Monica Bellucci who the hell am I to complain? I just don't love him in the ad itself. The girls' poses are very precise, and unfortunately by comparison his looks like that just happened to be how M&M caught him when they snapped it.