Dior_cotoure: on one hand I agree with you as I personally kind of prefer older more subtle (kinda) McQueen. On the other hand I don't think this is worse, it just speaks in another way, a more direct, theatrical and perhaps more violent way moreso than the more disturbing elements used before. Which of those you like best is up to each of us.
Bidwell said:
More drama drag (mq) queen antics...This is precisely the sort of histrionics I see as the final deathblow to an increasingly frivolous industry.
To those who are so enthralled by this, it is only to look at and fantasize about (or pull apart/emulate/study if your a fashion student).
It has no life off the pretentious catwalk. He makes a living off much cheaper streetwear. No one is going to dress like that or come close. It is visual masturbation in a very gay aesthetic and I find it at least pointless if not tired and at most misogynist.
I want to see something attune with society today NOT MORE OF THE SAME OLD CIRCUS FARE.
It's fascinating to see someone speak from a point of which I'm not shure is contemporary or plain old-fashioned. Personally, I'm tired of people talking about the bloody "rules" of the catwalk, and the functionality of the runway-show. All the designers have showroom-appointments for buyers, so why not stage the runway as a mood-setter? A theatrical and story-telling show in which you can get a real taste of what this collection is about, not just "hey... here are the clothes" - why not? Because it's "visual mastrubation"? All the catwalk shows are about the visuals, why not make it flashy? I'm not asking this to be difficult, but because you speak like this isn't your opinion, but from a critical analysis point of view. So for the sake of discussion, why not throw a show? The pieces McQueen sells are amazing because of the subtle details, the cuts, the fabrics and the mood they carry - something that would be lost if you just put it on a model, put some black eyeliner and mascara on them and tell them to "walk down there, strike a pose and walk back, and do it fast!".
For me, Alexander McQueen is a breath of fresh air, because he knows no limits, if it's painting a dress on stage with machines, coming out in a bunnysuit or putting on a show of pure theatrical gothicness like this. He doesn't do this to show "this is what you are gonna wear this autumn!", or the newest it-bag. This doesn't dress the celebs or the socialites, but it gives off energy, inspiration and presents a mood to a collection, instead of just showing off the pieces. I think that's a much better use of the catwalk than walking people up and down.
It's a artsy-fartsy, and maybe vain way to see it, but come on, do we really need LESS diversity so we can look at the clothes without beeing scared of the makeup or *gasp* not picture ourselves in all the pretty dresses and it-bags?
Oh, and please, explain what is "gay" about his aesthetics?