MODERATOR'S NOTE: Please can all of theFashionSpot's forum members remind themselves of the Forum Rules. Thank you.
Chinor1z said:I have to say, it's a really.... weird piece.
I mean, just how functional is it really? Is a guy REALLY going to wear it? It's quite a feminine piece that masquerades as a masculine one what with all the typical biker/military stylings but then with no sleeves.
It reminds me of when a girl is given a guy's jacket to wear over their shoulders with their arms inside (think after a prom dance). That is, it looks fine on Kate, but if I saw it on a guy I'd just say it looked odd. The capes Hedi designed this season are just plain strange and are this weird mix of classic Hedi and a step towards haute couture. Unfortunately, I don't see it being a successful step. The final product just looks like the wearer is trying too hard. In my opinion, the clothes should draw attention to the wearer, not the other way around. Hedi's designs all did that in the past in my opinion. The clothes were of course admired and envied, but it was all about that silhouette, the overall "look", how it presented the wearer.
That being said,
I'll stay with the items that actually have sleeves, thanks.
tricotineacetat said:Well I don´t see what´s wrong with this season´s tailored capes, at least the one from look 1 that was also presented in grain de poudre with satin collar. I agree they are not for everybody but they might work well on a person with a small shoulders. I´d totally see myself wearing one with black cavalry boots and a long knitted skarf around the neck... I actually liked the way the boys looked fragile, almost a bit feminine in the long capes, I think it´s typically Hedi and a natural evolution of what he always did - even back in the Saint Laurent days, there were pieces that were not necessarily designed for the sake of wearability but to create an image - this season in particular was a bit more daring, androgynous as usual but it´s not like these capes were looking ridiculous or contrived worn - leave this to Raf to create superhero-worthy, experimental clothes for the brave (especially his beloved cloaks).
Chinor1z said:Well, I think it is one thing to appreciate them on the catwalk (which I definitely did, along with those crazy knit cape/cloaks too), but if I saw someone walking down the street wearing it i would definitely think they were trying too hard.
What I liked about a lot of the Dior Homme designs of the past was their wonderful balance of wearability and opulence. You would stand out when wearing Dior, but I never saw it in an 'attention crusader' sort of way.
Long story short, I like my shirts and outerwear to have sleeves! hahahaha
faust said:Hell yea, the capes were the BEST part of the collection.
tekken418 said:i think kate look really good in that capes