Project Runway Season 3

[Orchide]

If Vincent doesn't go next, this show will lose even more credibility imo.
He is consistently always in the bottom 2 and fights/argues with the judges, can't work well on teams and makes clothes that are a joke.
A fruit bowl as a hat?
The Twiggy "pocket" dress?
His space cadet lime green pageant gown?
The dog walking outfit was a plain black shift...and yes, lest we forget the "refrigerator" boxy long sheath with "children's drawings" splashed haphazardly across the front...

 

[mundodabolsa]

What I can't get over is how the judges' have been consistently on top of people for poor construction, then don't even mention that Vincent's model would have had her breasts out for everyone to see if not for that sports bra-like thing.

 

[cestmagique]

If Vincent doesn't go next, this show will lose even more credibility imo.
He is consistently always in the bottom 2 and fights/argues with the judges, can't work well on teams and makes clothes that are a joke.
A fruit bowl as a hat?
The Twiggy "pocket" dress?
His space cadet lime green pageant gown?
The dog walking outfit was a plain black shift...and yes, lest we forget the "refrigerator" boxy long sheath with "children's drawings" splashed haphazardly across the front...

agreed. I definitely don't understand his "vision".

 

[kochie332]

because he doesnt have a vision. he has to go!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[miss6o]

i havent been here in awhile cause i had to host some guest for few weeks, but i watched the missed episodes today. i was sad to see bradley and alison go. i dont see vincents vision either, but he is fun to watch cause he is so disoriented and crazy.. cant wait for the next ep!

 

[dbear1000]

agreed. I definitely don't understand his "vision".

What I don't understand is the Judges visions!

 

[Yellowstar09]

QUOTE] Obvioulsy, the producer's think Vincent is good TV and creates drama. HE doesn't create drama, THE PRODUCERS create drama by keeping him on!!!!! Honestly, unlike Santino from last season, who made some crappy stuff and was 'good tv', Vincent does NOT make me come back week after week to see what he does next. In fact, from reading this thread, it seems as though Vincent is turning people off from Project Runway, as opposed to bringing them back.....[/quote]

Actually, I don't think the producers have that much input, the producers can make suggestions about whom they rather be elimanted but the judges have the final say. If you read's Andy's blog on Bravo's site, he said that the suggestions that Vincent was kept for good TV is silly and said I personally would rather have seen Alison continue. Cuddles(Alison as my sister calls her) is just a victim of these judges insane decision making. Seriously what were they thinking? And, by they way did anyone read the blurb on the daily news that basically said that Cuddles was kicked out because Heidi's hates her so much -- this was all in codes of course. Still will miss Cuddles...

As for the upcoming challenge who the heck is the everyday woman? Is it an eliminated model, contestant? Past judge perhaps? Sarah Jessica Parker? Debra Messing? Heidi's Mom? and I will go out on limb because of Angela reaction, the contestant's mother?

I frankly think its evil to tell us a little snipets of the future challenge to keep us guessing. Damn you producers. Seriously, EVIL worst then ANTM even Greys.

 

[Nocturnal_Antix]

I don't get this season, it doesn't even remotely touch the other two seasons, at all, and what is up with the judges!

 

[StyleSnob]

I agree, if Project Runway keeps eliminating the wrong designers the show is going to lose all credibility! And soon all the fabulous aspiring designers will see the show as a joke, and not audition to go on.

 

[sarah13]

I agree Style Snob. It will lose its "seriousness of purpose" Or whatever Tim said. He is the one that keeps the integrity of the show.

 

[allybobally]

Maybe I'm being an elitist, but if it's Martha Stewart for the next challenge, I'm going to be so disappointed! I want conceptual stuff, and Project Runway usually plays it pretty safe, but at least most of the challenges give them no limit to how crazy they can be. The INC (like last season's BR challenge) is, of course, one of the few challenges where they really have to be realistic, since the clothing will be sold in select stores. But Martha Stewart? We already had our boring challenge, an awful outfit won (rather than Alison/Keith/Jeffrey's amazing one), and I'm ready to move on.

Talk about dowdy! This season has been so disappointing. Get Michael Kors off the panel. He doesn't give an experienced angle as a designer, he just sounds like a one note with bad, old-fashioned taste. Vera was much better, in my opinion. Do you think Alison would have stayed if she was judging that day?

(ps...rachel zoe is an idiot.)

 

[serena775]

QUOTE] Obvioulsy, the producer's think Vincent is good TV and creates drama. HE doesn't create drama, THE PRODUCERS create drama by keeping him on!!!!! Honestly, unlike Santino from last season, who made some crappy stuff and was 'good tv', Vincent does NOT make me come back week after week to see what he does next. In fact, from reading this thread, it seems as though Vincent is turning people off from Project Runway, as opposed to bringing them back.....

Actually, I don't think the producers have that much input, the producers can make suggestions about whom they rather be elimanted but the judges have the final say. If you read's Andy's blog on Bravo's site, he said that the suggestions that Vincent was kept for good TV is silly and said I personally would rather have seen Alison continue. Cuddles(Alison as my sister calls her) is just a victim of these judges insane decision making. Seriously what were they thinking? And, by they way did anyone read the blurb on the daily news that basically said that Cuddles was kicked out because Heidi's hates her so much -- this was all in codes of course. Still will miss Cuddles...

As for the upcoming challenge who the heck is the everyday woman? Is it an eliminated model, contestant? Past judge perhaps? Sarah Jessica Parker? Debra Messing? Heidi's Mom? and I will go out on limb because of Angela reaction, the contestant's mother?

I frankly think its evil to tell us a little snipets of the future challenge to keep us guessing. Damn you producers. Seriously, EVIL worst then ANTM even Greys.[/quote]

Awwwwwww.....cuddles

 

[Lady-Penelope]

(ps...rachel zoe is an idiot.)

Can you tell me why everyone hates this rachel person? I'm kind of out of the loop.

 

[cestmagique]

Talk about dowdy! This season has been so disappointing. Get Michael Kors off the panel. He doesn't give an experienced angle as a designer, he just sounds like a one note with bad, old-fashioned taste. Vera was much better, in my opinion. Do you think Alison would have stayed if she was judging that day?

I bet she would have. But then I have no idea what crazy logic the judges follow. Vincent consistently sucks but stayed on, whereas Alison made one "mistake" (that I liked) and was kicked off. I thought more attention was paid to overall performance than that. Michael Kors is alright imo, I just don't tend to agree with him. Vera was great though.

 

[Yellowstar09]

You guys check out this PR recap.. its hysterical.

http://fourfour.typepad.com/fourfour/2006/08/i_know_this_wor.html#more

 

[r_r_r]

lol that was hilarious, "she's dead everybody!" and "Brushing your face, huh? How...sanitary"

 

[Yellowstar09]

LOL..seriously.. did u listen to sound clip of what the Sopranos sounded in her head?? So funny...

 

[eternitygoddess]

Vincent's last dress was TERRIBLE. I've never seen anything like it. The bodice was cut with those awful triangles.

It look like he got a huge piece of paper, wrapped it around the model, and stuck more papers on it. It look like a kindergartener's art project.

 

[sarah13]

Am going to be traveling for work this Wednesday and will miss this weeks PR Guess I will have to catch it the following week before the new one. But there is no way I will be able to stay off the boards ... Oh well.

 

[Ianastar]

because he doesnt have a vision. he has to go!!!!!!!!!!!

Agreed!!!!