Naomi's ed, I'm sorry to say, bores me to death. I wish it hadn't been a studio shoot, and even more so, that it hadn't been a themed studio shoot. All the white is just disinteresting, especially against the bland background, and really no amount of post-Photoshop light effects will make mediocre photography any better. Naomi looks fantastic though, regardless of this commercial, borderline catalogue-esque mess. Why they didn't, couldn't or wouldn't do more with her, therefore, is beyond me.
I really like the last picture of Liv -- her face is truly gorgeous. The second picture isn't bad either, but I really don't understand why UK Elle insists to use cover shots inside also. Both the subscriber's and newsstands' cover shots inside? Instead of two completely new shots? Or even just one? Really? I have a hard time believing that there were really no other print-worthy photos among her outtakes than these, and it's really rather disappointing to find the cover shots inside also, considering how few photos there are inside to begin with.