October 2, 2009
Special Report
Balmain vs. Balenciaga
By SUZY MENKES
PARIS — Thursday marked the great standoff between Balmain and Balenciaga, two storied couture houses that have both — in very different ways — gone pop with new designers.
Here is the verdict from cyberspace: Balenciaga, 41 Twitters in an hour after the show; and in the same time, Balmain, 75.
If you Google Balmain and Christophe Decarnin, 166,000 results appear (after the designer’s four years at the house). For Balenciaga and Nicolas Ghesquière, it is 70,900 after 12 years at the helm.
How unfair it is that the Balmain designer should have twice the attention of the other. For the collection sent out by Mr. Ghesquière on Thursday was by far the more original and inventive —a return to the futuristic and dynamic look he first delivered at Balenciaga.
Not that Balmain was a bad collection. It was repetitive, but full of energy and a raw sexual charge rarely seen these days on the catwalks. It was based on a military theme — all sparkling epaulets, jangling medals and torn denim tail coats. The dirty-blonde models strode out to the 1980s hip-hop beat of “Rappers’ Delight” by the Sugar Hill Gang. They were certainly a snapper’s delight — the collection will be a knockout as a video and great as an online slide-show.
Is fashion creativity still the most relevant issue? The spring/summer 2010 Paris shows are having their first season since social networking became a far bigger influence on fashion than editors, or even models and celebrities. If you look at the numbers, the fashion people out there have spoken, even if the judgment is influenced by the Hollywood factor of Rihanna and Beyoncé wearing Balmain or the niche in which Mr. Ghesquière deliberately hides himself.
“I do think about how things will look on screen — it’s very important,” said Mr. Ghesquière before sending out a turbo-powered show that took the designer back to his stark, space-age roots at Balenciaga and junked last season’s drape-and-shape cocktail dresses with a sheen of bourgeois glamour.
“Urban, but with authenticity and rusticity,” said Mr. Ghesquière, who admitted that he had thought “deeply” about this collection.
It had the feeling of clothes never before seen quite like this, even if the first silhouettes of skinny pants — but with hooded vests — touched on the geometry that the designer previously had drawn up for Balenciaga.
But the point of the moto-cross look, down to its ankle-stud boots with cylinder heels, was that it was infused with extraordinary fabric research and gulps of vivid color. The vermilion, green or yellow even appeared as spots at the inner corners of the models’ eyes, as well as in blocks of bright shades emerging from the side of a sliced-away leather dress.
More than ever, this collection seemed like a computerized image, with its stark, clear lines and white shirts as a backdrop. Yet it had three-dimensional depth, with materials intriguing in their mixes of textures and visual contrasts. The audience could see up close the woven raffia vest or porcupine spikes of leather on a skirt hem as the models walked through daylight streaming in from the gilded windows of the grand Hôtel de Crillon.
But anyone who thought that this collection had abandoned the grown-up ladies of last season should have listened to Catherine Deneuve, whose new movie is called “Mere et Filles” or “Mothers and Daughters,” and who sat in the front row with a posse of young French actresses.
“He is so inventive in materials and silhouettes,” said Ms. Deneuve, a French icon, referring to a zippered column dress with a synthetic/organic surface. What a shame that this subtlety won’t play online the same way it did to the live audience.
There was absolutely no subtlety at the Balmain show, which was hard — literally, as metal mesh dresses featured scooped-out, braless necklines; or figuratively, as laces were worked through metal eyelets on leather pants. A belt was even impregnated by bullets.
“It’s warrior women and the military, with a mix of different times and a touch of ‘Mad Max,”’ Mr. Decarnin said backstage, summing up this tough not-so-chic look that has a generation of rich kids in its thrall.
For these are not inexpensive clothes. The skill needed to create such dramatic pieces is exceptional: the cut of the military coats; the threading through of metal mesh and sequins; the lattice weave of python and leather for the pants. And throughout, the skillful cutting that gave the sense of clothes falling onto bare bodies.
There was more than a hint of Gianni Versace in his heyday — but how could you not associate the late designer with metal mesh and a 1980s vibe? And new-millennium Balmain has definitely caught the fashion moment, as well as the attention of a whole wide world of bloggers, Tweeters and cyberspace image makers. They see in Mr. Decarnin the vibe of the moment: love it, grab it, own it, have fun with it. MySpace is his space.