Style battle: Mary Kate, Ashley or Kate Moss?

[LeonieAlexandria]

I sometimes like Kate Moss' outfits, but i do adore Ashleys. I love elegant,classy,simple clothes and ashley definitley wears fantastic combinations.

 

[GCc]

dude,
how can you even COMPARE the great Kate Moss with the troll sisters?!!

come on!

 

[newprincesita]

dude,
how can you even COMPARE the great Kate Moss with the troll sisters?!!

come on!

It´s kinda harsh a statement, but yeah, I gotta agree.
Kate can dress up and down but she always manages to be sexy and feminine, and all she wears fits her like a glove. Mk & A almost always look disheveled and umm dare I say scared (maybe it´s the paparazzis), and they seem to wear too big clothes for they mini-bodyframes.

 

[Asha123]

/\ Yes, they do where clothes that are too big for them, but they are very short! I love Kate Moss I can't see any reason to compare them because Kate Moss will win, she is elagant, fashionable, classy and she has the ability to wear anything thrown at her!

 

[WAVE]

KATE MOSS! KATE MOSS! KATE MOSS ...Definitely. she could be wearing everything and still looking extremely elegant and classy; it' s not the same for the Olsen sisters...I mean, sometimes their style is cool, but most of the times they seem clumsy in those outfits!

 

[susie_bubble]

I only say Kate Moss because she's older, wiser and of course she has an intuitive sense of how to put her outfits together. Rarely does she get it wrong.

However....I love the Olsen twins' experimentation, in particular MK who has a really cute way of layering and accessorising. Ashley is a bit more conventional but still very stylish. Sure, they might get it wrong, but that takes fashion bravada. They certainly don't look like the average teen Hollywood stars.....and at only 18, their style can only get better and better till they surpass Kate Moss probably.

 

[Nader]

this thread is hilarious.

yeah, like there's any competition. if kate moss had an ingrown toenail it in itself would have more style than the twins

 

[miss.fashionista]

can't believe there is a thread on this....*sigh*

 

[twilight fairy]

Wow.!

I apologize for making such a stupid, ridiculous thread. Seems like anything that suggestively diminishes Kate Moss' superiority gets absolutely ridiculed. I never meant to question Kate Moss' style and choice of clothes, I never said MK&A were even in the same league...
I was merely interested in the number of people who preferred one over the other, because it seemed to me MK&A style popularity had grown dramatically over the past year, therefore I was curious as to how many people here on tFS preferred MK&A's style to Kate's, or vice versa.
I am not stupid, I know that MK&A are teenagers and Kate is a woman, she has had her experiences in the fashion industry like no other person. Yet that doesn't mean that other people can't like MK&A's style more than hers. I respect Kate and I like her style (I have like a million candids of her on my comp.) but guys, please don't take everything so incredibly offensively! Same with the Victoria copied Kate, Sienna copied Kate, Nicole Richie copied Kate, everyone copied Kate thing..
I understand how easy it is to love someone like Kate Moss who is the ultimate trend-setter in England.
Yet, I think in the US, more people look up to MK&A as "the trendsetters", at least that is my impression on the amounts of MK&A lookalikes all over lj. That is why I created this thread. It seemed to me these celebrities seemed to be the trendsetters for a lot of things.

And now could I kindly ask the moderators to close this thread, since I cannot help feeling slightly belittled and offended at some of these comments, especially since I never even intended to start a fight or an argument.

 

[susie_bubble]

Twilight...I don't think this thread is stupid at all. It is possible to compare the three. Age shudn't really be an issue. Issue is do their outfits look good on them and how well have they put them together?? I certainly don't think Kate is untouchable!

 

[niki03]

Aww! I wish that you weren't made to feel that way twilight..I totally get where you are coming from..The Olsen's style is definitely as popular as Kate's and they have popularized many trends..I, for one, enjoy following both of their styles equally and find it to be an interesting comparison

 

[fie]

LOL How can there be a battle for style between Mary Kate, Ashley or Kate Moss?
Let these two little ugly trollops battle it out themself, and leave Kate Moss out of it she will win hands down and is NEVER going to be competition for these girls.

 

[mas]

Wonered why she stays looking skinny????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Check this out! SHOCKING!!!!!!!

http://www.gawker.com/news/drugs/index.php#kate-moss-in-cocaine-nonshocker-contd-125768

 

[Fox in the Snow]

erm, Mary Kate always looks like a muppet & Kate Moss always looks divine.

not too much in the vs. dep't going on there

 

[LoveKylie]

Twilight Fairy (I just felt the need to send you some flowers =) )


I say, Kate.

 

[oolie coco]

I like this thread ... if people don't like it they don't have to come in here and crap all over it. It's interesting. everyone will have different opinions and personal preferences.

 

[IsaMaus]

Mk

Twilight , I love the thread.


I ADORE MK's style... She is the best looking woman in showbusiness (just my opinion, Kate fans please dont get offended). She can wear anything and LOOK
AMAZING!!!

http://www.detikhot.com/content_images/content/230/2005/4/5/marykate-d.jpg

http://www.hossli.com/celebrity/images02/2005- 0206_marykate.jpg

 

[Gonzo]

Kate.

 

[anatolska]

Kate, ovbio, ademas las otras no son mujeres, si no, trols.

 

[MTRLBY]

its obvious that everyone is going to answer kate moss.
but still, i give kudos to mary kate. she has guts to go out in some of those outfits, and i personally find her aesthetic sorta cool.