|BellaDonna|
Active Member
- Joined
- Jun 1, 2008
- Messages
- 3,613
- Reaction score
- 0
Just FYI, Kira said if you're NOT black and NOT American, you will NOT win the competition. In other words, if you ARE an African-American, you WILL win the competition (and Devyn, who is in Naomi's own words "a black girl" - she's actually mixed though - and also an American, won last season). Naomi doesn't determine the winner, the client does, so whether Naomi wanted Zilin to win or not is irrelevant.
Naomi misinterpreted it as if you're black and not American, which means you're a non-American African like Khadisha, you will not win. And it was her blowing up this misunderstanding in front of Frederic Fekkai that caused Kira so much trauma.
We don't know what Kira said to Afiya, but Afiya said Kira said a black girl would not win. It is also possible Afiya misinterpreted it since even Naomi misinterpreted Kira's sentence.
As for how Naomi treated her, I agree it didn't seem much different than how she treated the others, but I felt like that didn't particularly matter. I think it was already too late. Naomi humiliated and ruined all of Kira's chances to win by shaming her in front of the client over a misunderstanding, so Kira was already defeated then. Continuing or not in the competition wouldn't have mattered either way.
But I agree, the way Kira went about her elimination speech was never going to work. Anne said so herself that the mentors were only there to guide them. That blaming speech was just another nail in the proverbial coffin.
And this is just an opinion and not in any way stating that's how Naomi is, but I doubt she actually cared about Kira. Ever since the Face US 1 Naomi has taken every opportunity she can get to cause drama and be the center of attention on all version of the Face. I felt like Naomi rushing into the elimination room was more for Naomi to be in the center of the action than it was about Kira.
i mean either way she still can't win, with that interpretation now she's implying Naomi is totally biased, prejudiced, and expressing favoritism to blacks and American girls for the win.
either way that comment was going to have things end badly. there's no escaping or justifying it - lost in translation or not, Naomi's hot head or not
Last edited by a moderator: