this is fun how, to me, your post invisibly highlights all the paradox i read here and there.
most people didn't like Michael Kors for Céline - but you found that it is "a very Michael Kors for Celine type of collection, but updated to look more youthful". and you are right, imo.
people who like this collection also think that Pilati "was "boring" "nothing new", "seen it all before"".
and people didn't like Ivanka (obviously, as she got fired), but you nailed that she was more "innovative" .....
all this makes me confirm that people like Phoebe more than they like her work for Céline - as they obviously miss "the eye" for noticing things you + others nailed.
Phoebe needs her own brand. Everybody knows that !
Sign her for her own thing !