Shoes : Yay or Nay? #4

[Lalique]

Don't saddle up in either of those , cowgirl! B)

 

[Lalique]

My post was a bit delayed.
I meant that for the lace-y shoes on the other page.
Nay to the Sam Edelmans, OK to the boots with stretch ( I'd go for the black ones unless you have lots of things to go with the reddish tan color) and yay for the wingtips. They're cool with a girl-y outfit, too.

 

[John_M.]

To be honest, I'm not really into spiked/studded heels (Post #17). It's just too much for me. I just don't see the style much in such shoes. I'd also be careful not to kick something unintentionally with those studs. The shape of these booties is perfectly fine, but I'm going (Moderate) Nay! because of the studded design at the back of these shoes and on the heels.

Two shoes for Post #19. The booties in Post #19 get a (Slight) Yay! from me. It's up to you whichever color you want. I approve of them. I'm just not into oxfords and brogues as much as most other femmes are. I just don't really like them all that much. However, I do think these are pretty nice. So tab me for Yay! for those lace-ups.


Go dress fabulously, and also don't forget to dress (and shop) with confidence!

 

[MimiV]

I say YAY to the Sam Edelmans, Judleberry! They're not trendy anymore, no, that's a fact, but they are still gorgeous shoes. If you're worried about looking like you followed the trend too late, I'd put them in the closet for a year or so - to me they are timeless

ediewho, YAY to the H&M boots ! But for the oxfords I say nay since I think they are going to be really uncomfortable.

 

[seamnoir]

S.O.S... need opinions asap.

NOTE: I've been obsessed with the Chloe 2007 Docs since forever. However, creepers are my uniform. I need one of these for casual wear. Please, "YAY" only one shoe:

Revolve, ForwardForward, Underground

1. JC Tardy Boots (fit my feet like a glove)
2. Alexander Wang Constance (hear they're hard to walk in)
3. Underground LE Creepers (only 50 pairs ever made)

TIA!

 

[myown]

^nay to them all..

 

[MimiV]

Yay to Alexander Wang!

 

[|BellaDonna|]

i guess yay to the tardy if there had to be one.
I do like the Wangs but the heel might make me hardly wear them or only wear on occasions without much walking or standing and if you have all those restrictions due to comfort you might as well not bother to buy em. but they are a great looking boot.
Creepers - not a fan of the style.
So that was my thought process.

 

[Dego]

Nay to all. Especially the Wangs.

 

[seamnoir]

haha thanks all, I loved all of your responses.

 

[John_M.]

Well, it really wouldn't be worth anything to just "yay" one pair of shoes if multiple shoes are yay-worthy (Post #25). So I'll do this in classic form: Yay! to the lace-up wedge boots, (Moderate) Yay! second boots, and (Very Slight) Nay! to the leather creepers.

So if you want me to just yay one of them to be my pick of the three, Yay! the first boots. They are the most manageable to me of the three. This, speaking as someone not really into lace-ups all that much.

 

[ambreit]

i'm on the fence...

zappos.com

 

[Dali]

seamnoir - Not my style, but I like the first ones the most.

ambreit - Nay

 

[Dego]

There are not enough NAYs in the world for anything clog-like.

 

[John_M.]

Fairly decent and manageable ankle boots. If you're just looking for a comfortable pair of low-heel boots, there's not much in me to dislike them. So the boots in Post #32 are getting a Yay! from me.

 

[Judleberry]

Thanks everyone! I think I will get the Sam Edelmans, is spite of the fact that they are a bit late on the trend, because when I try them on with black tights, it's like they are part of my leg and are really unnoticable so won't detract from any outfit, until I turn round and unleash the weapon on the back!

I'd also be careful not to kick something unintentionally with those studs.

I know, right?! They could actually kill someone I think

 

[lifeistiffanyblu]

ambreit I have to say a big fat NAY

 

[Riniii]

What do you think of this pair? It's available in both black & brown. I have to say that although I like the brown one most, black is more versatile.

From Haute & Rebellious

 

[John_M.]

Lace-up ankle boots in Post #38. Not real fond of lace-up boots all that much, and the shape of the platform base and the high heels don't appeal to me too much. So I'm going (Moderate) Nay! to these.

 

[ediewho]

ambreit nay

Riniii yay, I like them both if you can handle that heel! (too much for me with the platform) both colours are pretty nice